arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2404.04485cs.HC
收藏

医生多数投票提高病理学中AI依赖的适当性

Majority Voting of Doctors Improves Appropriateness of AI Reliance in Pathology

Hongyan Gu, Chunxu Yang, Shino Magaki, Neda Zarrin-Khameh, Nelli S. Lakis, Inma Cobos, Negar Khanlou, Xinhai R. Zhang, Jasmeet Assi, Joshua T. Byers, Ameer Hamz… 展开作者

Hongyan Gu, Chunxu Yang, Shino Magaki, Neda Zarrin-Khameh, Nelli S. Lakis, Inma Cobos, Negar Khanlou, Xinhai R. Zhang, Jasmeet Assi, Joshua T. Byers, Ameer Hamza, Karam Han, Anders Meyer, Hilda Mirbaha, Carrie A. Mohila, Todd M. Stevens, Sara L. Stone, Wenzhong Yan, Mohammad Haeri, Xiang 'Anthony' Chen

AI总结:

本文通过32名医疗专业人员的多机构研究验证多数投票可促进病理医生适当依赖AI,三人小组即可显著提升RAIR、RSR及核分裂象检测效果。

摘要:

随着人工智能(AI)在医疗决策中不断取得进展,确保医生对AI形成适当依赖以避免不良结果的需求日益增长。然而,现有用于实现适当AI依赖的方法在应用于医疗领域时可能面临挑战。鉴于此,本研究采用并验证了一种替代方法——多数投票——以促进医疗决策中对AI的适当依赖。该验证通过一项多机构用户研究完成,研究涉及32名具有不同背景的医疗专业人员,聚焦于在肿瘤图像中视觉检测一种模式——核分裂象——的病理学任务。在此,多数投票过程通过综合一组病理学医生(病理学家)在AI辅助下作出的决策来实施。研究使用两个指标评估AI依赖的适当性:相对AI依赖(Relative AI Reliance,RAIR)和相对自我依赖(Relative Self-Reliance,RSR)。结果显示,即使仅有三名病理学家组成的小组,与一名病理学家协同AI作出的决策相比,多数投票决策也显著提高了RAIR和RSR,分别提高约9%和31%。这种适当性的提升带来了核分裂象检测中精确率和召回率的改善。尽管本研究以病理学为中心,但我们认为这些洞见可以扩展到涉及类似视觉任务的一般高风险决策过程。

英文摘要:

As Artificial Intelligence (AI) making advancements in medical decision-making, there is a growing need to ensure doctors develop appropriate reliance on AI to avoid adverse outcomes. However, existing methods in enabling appropriate AI reliance might encounter challenges while being applied in the medical domain. With this regard, this work employs and provides the validation of an alternative approach -- majority voting -- to facilitate appropriate reliance on AI in medical decision-making. This is achieved by a multi-institutional user study involving 32 medical professionals with various backgrounds, focusing on the pathology task of visually detecting a pattern, mitoses, in tumor images. Here, the majority voting process was conducted by synthesizing decisions under AI assistance from a group of pathology doctors (pathologists). Two metrics were used to evaluate the appropriateness of AI reliance: Relative AI Reliance (RAIR) and Relative Self-Reliance (RSR). Results showed that even with groups of three pathologists, majority-voted decisions significantly increased both RAIR and RSR -- by approximately 9% and 31%, respectively -- compared to decisions made by one pathologist collaborating with AI. This increased appropriateness resulted in better precision and recall in the detection of mitoses. While our study is centered on pathology, we believe these insights can be extended to general high-stakes decision-making processes involving similar visual tasks.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑