互联网的协议性批判:IPFS与SecureScuttleButt项目比较
Critiques protocolaires d'Internet: comparaison des projets IPFS et SecureScuttleButt
AI总结:
本文通过批判性话语分析比较IPFS和SecureScuttleButt两个去中心化协议项目,揭示其基础设施批判的多样性及不同替代方案中的能动性维度。
摘要:
本文探讨了两个作为当前互联网协议状态替代方案的关键基础设施提案:IPFS(星际文件系统)和Scuttlebutt,并强调这些技术事业的政治先验与争论。为此,我提议以批判性话语分析的方式分析这两个系统开发者的话语。本文突出了一种对互联网体制的特定批判形式:基础设施批判,并通过比较研究展现其多样性。通过这两个案例研究,我们将看到当前互联网时空实现的不同替代方案如何使我们识别这些劫持与替代行为的能动性维度,从而刻画出两种截然不同的去中心化协议路径,尽管它们在技术上具有相似性。
英文摘要:
This paper explores two critical infrastructure proposals as alternatives to the current state of the Internet protocols: IPFS (Interplanetary File System) and Scuttlebutt, highlighting the political a priori and debates of these technical enterprises. To do so, I propose to analyze the discourses of the developers of these two systems in the mode of a critical discourse analysis.This article highlights a particular form of criticism of Internet regimes: infrastructural criticism, and highlights its variety through a comparative study. Through these two case studies, we will see how different alternatives to the current spatio-temporal implementations of the Internet allow us to identify the agency dimensions of these acts of hijacking and substitution, characterizing two quite different approaches to decentralized protocols, yet linked by a technical similarity.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。