arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2403.17798econ.GNq-fin.EC
收藏

规划、实施和发布卫生经济模型软件时的伦理考量:一项新提案

Ethical considerations when planning, implementing and releasing health economic model software: a new proposal

Matthew P Hamilton, Caroline Gao, Jonathan Karnon, Luis Salvador-Carulla, Sue M Cotton, Cathrine Mihalopoulos

AI总结:

本文提出计算卫生经济模型(CHEMs)开发应遵循研究伦理,并确立了透明、可重用、可更新(TRU)的六项评估标准,以规范软件规划、实施与发布,推动相关指南完善及基础设施投资。

摘要:

大多数卫生经济分析都是在计算机辅助下完成的。然而,将卫生经济模型作为软件(或计算卫生经济模型(CHEMs))实施的研究伦理却鲜为人知。我们提出,CHEMs的开发者和资助者应遵循研究伦理原则,并追求以下目标:(i) 社会可接受的用户需求和设计规范;(ii) 符合目的的实施;以及(iii) 具有社会效益的发布后使用。我们进一步提出,一个透明(T)、可重用(R)和可更新(U)的CHEM表明项目团队在很大程度上已实现这些目标。我们提出了评估TRU CHEMs的六项标准:(T1) 软件文件公开可用;(T2) 开发者贡献和关于适当使用的判断易于识别;(R1) 编程实践促进模型组件的独立重用;(R2) 许可证允许重用和衍生作品;(U1) 维护基础设施已到位;以及(U2) 发布版本被系统地重新测试和弃用。现有的CHEMs中很少有能满足所有TRU标准的。解决这些局限性将需要制定新的和更新的良好实践指南,并由政府和其他研究资助者投资于支持性基础设施和人力资本。

英文摘要:

Most health economic analyses are undertaken with the aid of computers. However, the research ethics of implementing health economic models as software (or computational health economic models (CHEMs)) are poorly understood. We propose that developers and funders of CHEMs should adhere to research ethics principles and pursue the goals of: (i) socially acceptable user requirements and design specifications; (ii) fit for purpose implementations; and (iii) socially beneficial post-release use. We further propose that a transparent (T), reusable (R) and updatable (U) CHEM is suggestive of a project team that has largely met these goals. We propose six criteria for assessing TRU CHEMs: (T1) software files are publicly available; (T2) developer contributions and judgments on appropriate use are easily identified; (R1) programming practices facilitate independent reuse of model components; (R2) licenses permit reuse and derivative works; (U1) maintenance infrastructure is in place; and (U2) releases are systematically retested and deprecated. Few existing CHEMs would meet all TRU criteria. Addressing these limitations will require the development of new and updated good practice guidelines and investments by governments and other research funders in enabling infrastructure and human capital.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑