arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2403.16906stat.ME
收藏

对独立概率分布的方差求和以估计重复概率

Adding variances of independent probability distributions to estimate probabilities of replication

Huw Llewelyn

AI总结:

本文提出通过将初始研究与重复研究的独立概率分布方差相加来估计重复研究中P值达到显著水平的概率,并据此指出当前功效计算方法可能低估所需样本量,从而为重复危机提供解释。

摘要:

如果一个连续变量的所有可能假设真实均值和所有可能观测均值的先验概率分布,都以所有数字的全集为条件(即在研究性质未知且贝叶斯先验分布尚无法估计之前),那么该先验概率分布将是均匀分布。由此可以推出,基于同一数据集的高斯概率分布与高斯似然分布是相同的。重复涉及进行两项独立研究,因此其建模方式为:将基于观测数据的概率分布的方差,与基于拟定样本量的重复研究的期望概率分布的方差相加。这样便可以估计在任何重复研究中,P值小于或等于0.05(双侧)或任何其他指定值的概率。同一模型还可用于在规划初始研究所需功效时估计样本量。如果这需要将方差加倍,那么所需样本量将是使用当前功效计算方法估计的样本量的两倍,这表明使用当前方法的研究功效不足。这些考虑或许可以用来解释重复危机。

英文摘要:

If the prior probability distributions of all possible hypothetical true means and all possible observed means of a continuous variable are conditional on the universal set of all numbers (i.e., before the nature of a study is known and a Bayesian prior distribution can be estimated), that prior probability distribution will be uniform. It would follow that a Gaussian probability distribution and a Gaussian likelihood distribution based on the same data set are identical. Replication involves doing two independent studies and is thus modelled by adding the variance of the probability distribution based on the observed data to the variance of the expected probability distribution of the replicating study based on its proposed sample size. This allows an estimate to be made of the probability that the P value will be less than or equal to 0.05 two sided (or any other specified value) in any replicating study. The same model can be used to estimate sample sizes when planning the required power of the initial study. If this requires doubling the variance, then this will require double the sample size estimated using current power calculations, suggesting that studies using current methods are underpowered. These considerations might be used to explain the replication crisis.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑