对结构化数据进行匿名化的目的是在保留数据统计特性的同时,保护数据中个体的隐私。已有大量研究探讨匿名化的脆弱性问题。本文聚焦强匿名化机制,对多篇知名攻击论文展开研究,发现了若干问题,所有这些问题都会导致风险被高估。首先,部分论文未能建立正确的统计推断基线(甚至完全没有建立基线),进而导致度量结果有误。值得注意的是,美国人口普查局(US Census Bureau)曾提出的重构攻击(该攻击促使其重新设计了信息披露方法)就犯了这个错误。我们提出了非成员框架(non-member framework),这是一种用于计算更准确的推断基线的改进方法,并给出了其运行示例。其次,部分论文未使用符合实际的成员先验概率,导致在报告精确率时得出错误的精确率度量结果。第三,部分论文以不必要的方式报告度量值,使得风险评估难以开展甚至无法进行。实际上,关于成员推断攻击的整个研究领域(涉及数十篇论文)都存在上述一种或两种错误。我们建议,成员推断相关论文应使用具有代表性的先验概率范围来报告精确率/召回率数值。
英文摘要:
The purpose of anonymizing structured data is to protect the privacy of individuals in the data while retaining the statistical properties of the data. There is a large body of work that examines anonymization vulnerabilities. Focusing on strong anonymization mechanisms, this paper examines a number of prominent attack papers and finds several problems, all of which lead to overstating risk. First, some papers fail to establish a correct statistical inference baseline (or any at all), leading to incorrect measures. Notably, the reconstruction attack from the US Census Bureau that led to a redesign of its disclosure method made this mistake. We propose the non-member framework, an improved method for how to compute a more accurate inference baseline, and give examples of its operation.
Second, some papers don't use a realistic membership base rate, leading to incorrect precision measures if precision is reported. Third, some papers unnecessarily report measures in such a way that it is difficult or impossible to assess risk. Virtually the entire literature on membership inference attacks, dozens of papers, make one or both of these errors. We propose that membership inference papers report precision/recall values using a representative range of base rates.
PrivacyMotiv: Vulnerability-Centered Persona Journeys for Empathic Privacy Reviews in UX Design
Northeastern University(东北大学);Institute of Design (ID) at Illinois Tech(伊利诺伊理工学院设计学院);Johns Hopkins University(约翰斯·霍普金斯大学);University of Notre Dame(圣母大学)