arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2403.02768cs.CY
收藏

关于国家安全信函的使用与报告的实证分析

An Empirical Analysis on the Use and Reporting of National Security Letters

Alex Bellon, Miro Haller, Andrey Labunets, Enze Liu, Stefan Savage

AI总结:

本文实证分析了国家安全信函(NSLs)透明度机制的有效性,发现公开数据因缺乏结构和背景难以解析且存在错误,据此为构建支持有效公众审计的透明度机制提供了见解。

摘要:

政府的调查和监视权力是调查犯罪和保护公共安全的重要工具。然而,由于这些工具必须秘密使用,要识别可能具有重大公共利益的滥用或使用变化是具有挑战性的。在本文中,我们在国家安全信函(NSLs)的背景下评估这一现象。NSLs是一种法律程序,授权美国联邦政府的部分机构出于国家安全目的请求某些信息。在最初对缺乏公众监督表示担忧之后,国会通过强制政府机构发布NSL使用的汇总统计数据,并允许私营部门在透明度报告中报告NSL信息,致力于提高透明度。其隐含目标是,这些透明度机制应通过使大规模滥用变得可见来加以威慑。我们通过仔细分析与NSL使用相关的所有公开数据来评估这些机制的运作效果。我们的研究结果表明,它们可能无法带来预期的公众审查,因为我们发现发布的信息由于缺乏结构和背景,需要大量的手动工作来收集和解析数据。此外,我们发现了错误(在我们向ODNI报告后已随后修复),这表明缺乏主动审计。总而言之,我们对NSL的案例研究为成功构建实现有效公众审计的透明度机制提供了见解和建议。

英文摘要:

Government investigatory and surveillance powers are important tools for examining crime and protecting public safety. However, since these tools must be employed in secret, it can be challenging to identify abuses or changes in use that could be of significant public interest. In this paper, we evaluate this phenomenon in the context of National Security Letters (NSLs). NSLs are a form of legal process that empowers parts of the United States federal government to request certain pieces of information for national security purposes. After initial concerns about the lack of public oversight, Congress worked to increase transparency by mandating government agencies to publish aggregated statistics on the NSL usage and by allowing the private sector to report information on NSLs in transparency reports. The implicit goal is that these transparency mechanisms should deter large-scale abuse by making it visible. We evaluate how well these mechanisms work by carefully analyzing the full range of publicly available data related to NSL use. Our findings suggest that they may not lead to the desired public scrutiny as we find published information requires significant manual effort to collect and parse data due to the lack of structure and context. Moreover, we discovered mistakes (subsequently fixed after our reporting to the ODNI), which suggests a lack of active auditing. Taken together, our case study of NSLs provides insights and suggestions for the successful construction of transparency mechanisms that enable effective public auditing.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑