arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2403.00111cs.SE
收藏

分类体系质量属性的汇编与评估

A compendium and evaluation of taxonomy quality attributes

Michael Unterkalmsteiner, Waleed Abdeen

AI总结:

针对分类体系质量缺乏可操作比较标准的问题,本文综述324篇文献,提出七个互不重叠的质量属性及内外部度量,并在六个分类体系上验证其有用性。

摘要:

引言:分类体系以简洁的方式捕捉特定领域的知识,并在同行之间建立共同理解。研究人员使用分类体系传达特定知识领域的信息或支持自动化任务,从业者则使用它们实现跨越组织边界的沟通。目标:尽管分类体系在软件工程中具有这一重要作用,但其质量很少得到评估。我们的目标是识别并定义分类体系质量属性,这些属性提供实用的度量,帮助研究人员和从业者比较分类体系,并选择最适合当前任务的分类体系。方法:我们综述了来自软件工程和信息系统研究的324篇出版物,并在提供质量属性和度量定义时对其进行综合。我们在来自三个领域的六个分类体系上评估了这些度量的有用性。结果:我们提出了七个质量属性的定义,并建议可用于评估分类体系质量的内部和外部度量。对于其中两个度量,我们提供了Python实现。我们发现这些度量有助于决定哪种分类体系最适合特定目的。结论:尽管存在若干创建分类体系的指南,但缺乏可操作的标准来比较分类体系。在本文中,我们通过从大量文献中综合出七个互不重叠的分类体系质量属性及相应度量来填补这一空白。未来工作包括对其有用性的进一步评估和实证验证。

英文摘要:

Introduction: Taxonomies capture knowledge about a particular domain in a succinct manner and establish a common understanding among peers. Researchers use taxonomies to convey information about a particular knowledge area or to support automation tasks, and practitioners use them to enable communication beyond organizational boundaries. Aims: Despite this important role of taxonomies in software engineering, their quality is seldom evaluated. Our aim is to identify and define taxonomy quality attributes that provide practical measurements, helping researchers and practitioners to compare taxonomies and choose the one most adequate for the task at hand. Methods: We reviewed 324 publications from software engineering and information systems research and synthesized, when provided, the definitions of quality attributes and measurements. We evaluated the usefulness of the measurements on six taxonomies from three domains. Results: We propose the definition of seven quality attributes and suggest internal and external measurements that can be used to assess a taxonomy's quality. For two measurements we provide implementations in Python. We found the measurements useful for deciding which taxonomy is best suited for a particular purpose. Conclusion: While there exist several guidelines for creating taxonomies, there is a lack of actionable criteria to compare taxonomies. In this paper, we fill this gap by synthesizing from a wealth of literature seven, non-overlapping taxonomy quality attributes and corresponding measurements. Future work encompasses their further evaluation of usefulness and empirical validation.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑