arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2402.18705cs.HCcs.CY
收藏

平台交换与保障机制如何发挥作用:Airbnb与Couchsurfing中的性风险案例

How Platform Exchange and Safeguards Matter: The Case of Sexual Risk in Airbnb and Couchsurfing

Skyler Wang

AI总结:

本文对比Airbnb和Couchsurfing,通过40名女性用户访谈揭示平台交换类型与保障机制如何影响性风险,发现协商交换与制度保障能降低风险,而互惠交换缺乏保障会增加用户脆弱性,并据此提出保护弱势用户的设计启示。

摘要:

近期CHI和CSCW的研究日益关注网络 hospitality 平台的设计如何塑造用户体验与关系结果。本文探究基于这些平台促成的交换类型,不同的风险因素是如何产生的。为此,我对比了两个主要的网络 hospitality 平台:一个促成协商交换(即 Airbnb),另一个促成互惠交换(即 Couchsurfing)。聚焦于性风险这一尚未充分探索的平台危险形式,基于对 40 名女性双平台用户的访谈,我认为 Airbnb 提供的约束性协商交换和制度保障通过三种机制降低了风险:将最初的房客-房东关系转化为买卖双方安排、稳定互动脚本以及使性暴力追责正式化。相反,Couchsurfing 对互惠交换的关注及保障机制的缺失,增加了用户在平台内外的性脆弱性。本研究展示了具有强烈亲社会动机的平台如何危及社交性,并提出了保护弱势用户群体的设计启示。

英文摘要:

Recent work in CHI and CSCW has devoted increasing attention to how the design of network hospitality platforms shapes user experiences and relational outcomes. In this article, I interrogate how different risk factors emerge based on the type of exchanges these platforms facilitate. To do so, I juxtapose two prominent network hospitality platforms: one facilitating negotiated exchange (i.e., Airbnb) with another facilitating reciprocal exchange (i.e., Couchsurfing). Homing in on sexual risk, an underexplored form of platform danger, and drawing on interviews with 40 female dual-platform users, I argue that Airbnb's provision of binding negotiated exchange and institutional safeguards reduces risk through three mechanisms: casting initial guest-host relation into a buyer-seller arrangement, stabilizing interactional scripts, and formalizing sexual violence recourse. Conversely, Couchsurfing's focus on reciprocal exchange and lack of safeguards increase sexual precarity for users both on- and off-platform. This study demonstrates how platforms with strong prosocial motivations can jeopardize sociality and concludes with design implications for protecting vulnerable user populations.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑