取代型科学
Displacing Science
AI总结:
该研究通过八年调研、多学科访谈及六十年4100万篇论文分析,证实颠覆性论文数量下降,阐释D-index的“取代”内涵,揭示联邦资助机构对颠覆性研究的支持偏低,提出功能等效原理并质疑AI对科学创新的成熟作用,以推动D-index合理应用与科研资助机制创新。
摘要:
近期关于论文颠覆指数(D-index)下降的研究引发了学者间的激烈争论,也受到了全球政策制定者与研究机构负责人的高度关注。为弥合政策制定者对D-index的兴趣与学者对其的质疑之间的鸿沟,本文总结了我们为期八年的调研所得的核心洞见,调研涵盖对九个学科科学家的访谈,以及对六十余年间4100万篇论文的分析。本研究证实了颠覆性论文数量的下降,回应了相关技术质疑,并作出了若干原创贡献:我们阐明D-index衡量的是新想法让旧想法过时的程度,提出“取代(Displacing)”可作为“D”的另一种解读;我们发现NIH、NSF等联邦资助机构支持颠覆性研究的可能性更低;我们还提出“功能等效原理”以解释科学中重组与取代机制的起源,强调并非所有创新问题都是组合型的,同时对AI是科学创新成熟解决方案的观点提出了挑战。本文旨在推动D-index在科研评价中得到更广泛、准确的应用,并为科学突破催生新的资助机制。
英文摘要:
Recent research on the decline in the paper disruption index (D-index) has sparked heated debates among scholars and garnered significant attention from policymakers and research institution leaders globally. To bridge the gap between policymakers' interest and scholars' skepticism about the D-index, we present this article summarizing key insights from our eight-year investigation, including interviews with scientists across nine disciplines and an analysis of 41 million papers over six decades. Our work confirms the decline in disruptive papers, addresses relevant technical concerns, and makes several original contributions: we clarify that the D-index measures how new ideas render old ones obsolete, suggesting 'Displacing' as an alternative interpretation for 'D'; we show that federal funding agencies like the NIH and NSF are less likely to support disruptive research; and we introduce the 'principle of functional equivalence' to explain the origins of recombining and displacing mechanisms in science, stressing that not all innovation problems are combinatorial, and challenging the belief that AI is the mature solution to scientific innovation. This article aims to promote broader and more accurate use of the D-index in research evaluation and to inspire new funding mechanisms for scientific breakthroughs.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。