arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2402.15439cs.HCcs.RO
收藏

通过受益者-认识论空间绘制多物种技术研究中的伦理张力

Charting Ethical Tensions in Multispecies Technology Research through Beneficiary-Epistemology Space

University of Nottingham(诺丁汉大学);The Open University(开放大学)
Steve Benford, Clara Mancini, Alan Chamberlain, Eike Schneiders, Simon Castle-Green, Joel Fischer, Ayse Kucukyilmaz, Guido Salimbeni, Victor Ngo, Pepita Barnard… 展开作者

Steve Benford, Clara Mancini, Alan Chamberlain, Eike Schneiders, Simon Castle-Green, Joel Fischer, Ayse Kucukyilmaz, Guido Salimbeni, Victor Ngo, Pepita Barnard, Matt Adams, Nick Tandavanitj, Ju Row Farr

AI总结:

本文通过反思 Cat Royale 多物种艺术项目的复杂伦理审批过程,提出受益者-认识论空间框架,用于揭示研究受益者与认识论层面的伦理张力,并帮助项目与 IRB 明确分歧、引入额外专业知识。

摘要:

虽然人机交互(HCI)领域广泛讨论了伦理挑战,但关于研究人员日常应对的伦理过程却鲜有报道。我们反思了一个多物种项目,该项目经历了一个尤为复杂的伦理审批过程。Cat Royale 是一项由艺术家主导的探索,旨在创作一件艺术品,让观众参与探索对自主系统的信任。该艺术品的形式是一个与三只猫玩耍的机器人。获得伦理批准需要与三个机构审查委员会(IRB)进行广泛对话,这些委员会涵盖计算机科学、兽医学和动物福利领域,由此引发了围绕猫的福利、感知到的益处与适当方法以及大学声誉风险等方面的张力。为了揭示这些张力,我们引入了受益者-认识论空间,该空间明确说明谁从研究中受益(人类或动物)以及潜在的认识论。将项目和 IRB 定位在这一空间中,有助于澄清张力,并凸显引入额外专业知识的机会。

英文摘要:

While ethical challenges are widely discussed in HCI, far less is reported about the ethical processes that researchers routinely navigate. We reflect on a multispecies project that negotiated an especially complex ethical approval process. Cat Royale was an artist-led exploration of creating an artwork to engage audiences in exploring trust in autonomous systems. The artwork took the form of a robot that played with three cats. Gaining ethical approval required an extensive dialogue with three Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) covering computer science, veterinary science and animal welfare, raising tensions around the welfare of the cats, perceived benefits and appropriate methods, and reputational risk to the University. To reveal these tensions we introduce beneficiary-epistemology space, that makes explicit who benefits from research (humans or animals) and underlying epistemologies. Positioning projects and IRBs in this space can help clarify tensions and highlight opportunities to recruit additional expertise.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑