arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2402.11314cs.MAcs.AI
收藏

用生成代理模拟城市规划中的多利益相关者决策

Simulating Multi-Stakeholder Decision-Making with Generative Agents in Urban Planning

Massachusetts Institute of Technology(麻省理工学院)

Jin Gao, Hanyong Xu, Luc Dao

AI总结:

本研究通过多生成代理系统模拟城市规划中的多利益相关者决策,探讨人口因素对集体决策的影响,并提升决策的公平性和效率。

摘要:

在城市规划中达成共识是一个复杂的过程,往往受到长时间谈判、权衡、权力动态和竞争性利益相关者利益的阻碍,导致效率低下和不公。大型语言模型(LLMs)的进步,特别是在知识转移、推理和规划方面的能力增强,使多生成代理系统的发展成为可能,为模拟不同利益相关者在争议性话题上的讨论和互动提供了有前途的方法。然而,应用此类系统也伴随着显著的社会和伦理风险,包括代表性不足、隐私问题以及来自代理意见趋同的偏见,还有由于提示不足或偏见导致的幻觉,以及基础模型的固有限制。为了评估这些因素的影响,我们结合不同层次的真实世界调查数据和人口细节,测试代理在两种决策价值框架下的表现:利他驱动和利益驱动,使用一个现实世界的城市重新规划挑战。这种方法评估了种族、性别和年龄等人口因素对多生成代理系统集体决策的影响。我们的实验结果表明,整合人口和生活价值观数据增强了代理输出的多样性和稳定性。此外,生成代理之间的交流提高了集体推理的质量。这些发现为决策者提供了一个预测框架,以预测利益相关者的反应,包括担忧、反对和支持。通过在公开发布前迭代优化提案,模拟方法促进了城市规划中更加公平和成本效益更高的决策。

英文摘要:

Reaching consensus in urban planning is a complex process often hindered by prolonged negotiations, trade-offs, power dynamics, and competing stakeholder interests, resulting in inefficiencies and inequities. Advances in large language models (LLMs), with their increasing capabilities in knowledge transfer, reasoning, and planning, have enabled the development of multi-generative agent systems, offering a promising approach to simulating discussions and interactions among diverse stakeholders on contentious topics. However, applying such systems also carries significant societal and ethical risks, including misrepresentation, privacy concerns, and biases stemming from opinion convergence among agents, hallucinations caused by insufficient or biased prompts, and the inherent limitations of foundation models. To evaluate the influence of these factors, we incorporate varying levels of real-world survey data and demographic detail to test agents' performance under two decision-making value frameworks: altruism-driven and interest-driven, using a real-world urban rezoning challenge. This approach evaluates the influence of demographic factors such as race, gender, and age on collective decision-making in the design of multi-generative agent systems. Our experimental results reveal that integrating demographic and life-value data enhances the diversity and stability of agent outputs. In addition, communication among generated agents improves the quality of collective reasoning. These findings provide a predictive framework for decision-makers to anticipate stakeholder reactions, including concerns, objections, and support. By enabling iterative refinement of proposals before public release, the simulated approach fosters more equitable and cost-effective decisions in urban planning.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑