配对匹配设计在极端噪声与分配下是最优的
The Pairwise Matching Design is Optimal under Extreme Noise and Assignments
AI总结:
本文在同时尾部准则下证明配对匹配设计在极端噪声与分配下渐近最优,且最优设计随机性介于完全随机化与确定性优化分配之间,并通过五种响应类型的模拟验证。
摘要:
我们考虑在等分配的双臂随机实验中,差分均值估计器在常见实验终点(如连续(回归)、发生率、比例、计数和未删失生存)下的总体表现。我们考虑两个随机性来源:受试者特定的分配和未观测的受试者特定测量的贡献。然后,我们在一个新的、更现实的“同时尾部准则”下检验均方误差(MSE)表现。我们证明,与其他区组设计相比,Greevy等人(2004)的配对匹配设计在该准则下渐近表现最优。我们还证明,最优设计必须比完全随机化更少随机,且比任何确定性的、优化的分配更随机。理论结果在全部五种响应类型中通过模拟得到支持。
英文摘要:
We consider the general performance of the difference-in-means estimator in an equally-allocated two-arm randomized experiment under common experimental endpoints such as continuous (regression), incidence, proportion, count and uncensored survival. We consider two sources of randomness: the subject-specific assignments and the contribution of unobserved subject-specific measurements. We then examine mean squared error (MSE) performance under a new, more realistic "simultaneous tail criterion". We prove that the pairwise matching design of Greevy et al. (2004) performs best asymptotically under this criterion when compared to other blocking designs. We also prove that the optimal design must be less random than complete randomization and more random than any deterministic, optimized allocation. Theoretical results are supported by simulations in all five response types.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。