霍华德-哈佛效应:制度对交叉不平等的再生产
The Howard-Harvard effect: Institutional reproduction of intersectional inequalities
AI总结:
本文研究了机构与作者交叉身份之间的主题对齐及其与声誉和科学影响的关系,发现少数族裔学者在使命驱动机构中主题特征被放大,在声誉高的机构中被削弱,揭示了系统性不平等。
摘要:
美国高等教育系统将科学生产和科学家的生产集中于少数机构中,这对被边缘化的学者及其关联的主题有影响。本文探讨了机构与不同交叉身份作者之间的主题对齐,以及与声誉和科学影响的关系。我们观察到霍华德-哈佛效应,即被边缘化学者的主题特征在使命驱动机构中被放大,在声誉高的机构中被削弱。结果表明,主题和研究影响存在一致的不平等。具体而言,我们观察到被边缘化学者与白人男性在引用和期刊影响上存在统计显著差异。美国声誉高的大学的整体研究特征与白人男性的研究特征高度相关,与被边缘化女性的研究特征高度负相关。此外,与更声誉高的机构关联的作者在引用和期刊影响上也表现出增加的不平等。学术机构和资助者被呼吁制定政策,以缓解阻碍美国实现完整科学生态系统系统性障碍。
英文摘要:
The US higher education system concentrates the production of science and scientists within a few institutions. This has implications for minoritized scholars and the topics with which they are disproportionately associated. This paper examines topical alignment between institutions and authors of varying intersectional identities, and the relationship with prestige and scientific impact. We observe a Howard-Harvard effect, in which the topical profile of minoritized scholars are amplified in mission-driven institutions and decreased in prestigious institutions. Results demonstrate a consistent pattern of inequality in topics and research impact. Specifically, we observe statistically significant differences between minoritized scholars and White men in citations and journal impact. The aggregate research profile of prestigious US universities is highly correlated with the research profile of White men, and highly negatively correlated with the research profile of minoritized women. Furthermore, authors affiliated with more prestigious institutions are associated with increasing inequalities in both citations and journal impact. Academic institutions and funders are called to create policies to mitigate the systemic barriers that prevent the United States from achieving a fully robust scientific ecosystem.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。