arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2402.00855q-fin.RM
收藏

长寿风险的均等化汇集与分担,又名“剥唐提猫的多种方法”

'Egalitarian pooling and sharing of longevity risk', a.k.a. 'The many ways to skin a tontine cat'

Jan L. M. Dhaene, Moshe A. Milevsky

AI总结:

针对异质性参与者的长寿风险汇集收益分配难题,本文提出建模框架,指出分配规则取决于池内社会凝聚力程度,精算科学仅能提供方法论而非唯一方案。

摘要:

保险精算师和金融经济学家对于以终身年金、固定收益养老金、自行年金化基金甚至唐提计划(tontine schemes)形式进行长寿风险汇集的社会效益几乎没有异议。实际上,与参与者独自承担风险相比,当参与者汇集其财务资源时,提供终身收入的折现价值或成本更低——换言之,在相同统计安全水平下,产生相似收入流所需的初始资本额更低。此外,当参与者的财务状况和寿命具有同质性时,对于如何在幸存者之间分配“收益”存在共识,即在幸存者之间平均分配,又名统一规则。可惜的是,鲜为人知且问题更大的是,当参与者在财富(缴费)和健康状况(长寿程度)上存在差异时,尤其是当汇集池规模相对较小时,如何在此类汇集池中分配收益。从去中心化风险分担(decentralized risk sharing,DRS)的双重视角来看,也会出现同样的问题。健康与收入之间的正相关关系,以及更富有的参与者可能寿命更长这一事实,正日益受到养老金和退休政策制定者的关注。基于这一动机,本文提出了一个建模框架,用于在参与者具有异质性时分配长寿风险汇集池的收入和福利(或唐提收益)。与新兴的去中心化风险分担文献类似,有几种同样合理的安排可用于在幸存者之间分配福利(又名“剥猫皮”)。此外,所选规则取决于长寿风险汇集池内部的社会凝聚力程度,范围从团结、利他到纯粹的个人主义。总而言之,精算科学实际上无法提供或保证唯一性,只能提供一种方法论。

英文摘要:

There is little disagreement among insurance actuaries and financial economists about the societal benefits of longevity-risk pooling in the form of life annuities, defined benefit pensions, self-annuitization funds, and even tontine schemes. Indeed, the discounted value or cost of providing an income for life is lower -- in other words, the amount of upfront capital required to generate a similar income stream with the same level of statistical safety is lower -- when participants pool their financial resources versus going it alone. Moreover, when participants' financial circumstances and lifespans are homogenous, there is consensus on how to share the "winnings" among survivors, namely by distributing them equally among survivors, a.k.a. a uniform rule. Alas, what is lesser-known and much more problematic is allocating the winnings in such a pool when participants differ in wealth (contributions) and health (longevity), especially when the pools are relatively small in size. The same problems arise when viewed from the dual perspective of decentralized risk sharing (DRS). The positive correlation between health and income and the fact that wealthier participants are likely to live longer is a growing concern among pension and retirement policymakers. With that motivation in mind, this paper offers a modelling framework for distributing longevity-risk pools' income and benefits (or tontine winnings) when participants are heterogeneous. Similar to the nascent literature on decentralized risk sharing, there are several equally plausible arrangements for sharing benefits (a.k.a. "skinning the cat") among survivors. Moreover, the selected rule depends on the extent of social cohesion within the longevity risk pool, ranging from solidarity and altruism to pure individualism. In sum, actuarial science cannot really offer or guarantee uniqueness, only a methodology.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑