敏捷工作量估算:Planning Poker、Bucket System与Affinity Estimation方法的准确率与效率比较
Agile Effort Estimation: Comparing the Accuracy and Efficiency of Planning Poker, Bucket System, and Affinity Estimation methods
AI总结:
本研究针对敏捷工作量估算,引入效率作为新维度,对比Planning Poker、Bucket System与Affinity Estimation三种方法,发现三者准确率无显著差异,但后两者耗时仅为前者一半。
摘要:
已发表的敏捷工作量估算研究主要聚焦于不同估算方法的准确率对比,而效率比较——即估算方法所耗费的时间——并未成为研究重点。然而,对于软件开发的实际应用而言,所需时间可能是企业的一项重要成本因素,尤其是在不同敏捷工作量估算的准确率相近的情况下。因此,本研究尝试引入效率(即使用一种方法所需的时间)作为额外的比较维度,对当前仅聚焦准确率的标准方法比较进行拓展。我们针对文献中尚未被对比过的三种敏捷工作量估算方法开展了比较,分别是Planning Poker(规划扑克)、Bucket System(桶系统)和Affinity Estimation(亲和估算)。为进行对比,我们选取了8支学生团队共29名学生,他们需在一门课程中使用所有工作量估算方法,且需在3周内完成一个编程项目。结果表明,在学生适应不同方法的使用后,各方法间的准确率无统计学显著差异,但效率存在显著差异。平均而言,Bucket System和Affinity Estimation方法的耗时仅为Planning Poker的一半。
英文摘要:
Published studies on agile effort estimation predominantly focus on comparisons of the accuracy of different estimation methods, while efficiency comparisons, i.e. how much time the estimation methods consume was not in the forefront. However, for practical use in software development, the time required can be a very important cost factor for enterprises, especially when the accuracy of different agile effort estimations is similar. In this study, we thus try to advance the current standard accuracy comparison between methods by introducing efficiency i.e. time it takes to use a method as an additional dimension of comparison. We conduct this comparison between three agile effort estimation methods that were not yet compared in the literature, namely Planning Poker, Bucket System and Affinity Estimation. For the comparison, we used eight student teams with 29 students that had to use all the effort estimation methods during the course where they had to finish a programming project in 3 weeks. The results indicate that after the students get used to using the different methods the accuracy between them is not statistically significantly different, however, the efficiency is. On average Bucket System and Affinity Estimation methods take half as much time as Planning Poker.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。