arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2401.12100econ.GNq-fin.EC
收藏

指标至关重要:对 Ward 等人发表于 Plos-One 2016 年论文《GDP 增长能否与环境影响脱钩?》的正式评论

Metrics matter, a Formal comment on Ward et al Plos-One 2016 paper : Is decoupling GDP growth from environmental impact possible?

Hervé Bercegol, Paul E. Brockway

AI总结:

本文修正 Ward 等 2016 年论文中 GDP 现价与物质使用口径错误,发现全球能源—GDP 相对脱钩更弱且物质—GDP 未脱钩,从而强化绝对脱钩不现实的结论。

摘要:

Ward 等人(2016)发表于 Plos-One 的论文是脱钩文献中一篇重要且被大量引用的论文。作者提供了1990—2015年全球层面以及部分国家在物质与能源消费和 GDP 方面增长的证据。他们发现只出现了相对脱钩,由此提出其核心主张:未来实现绝对脱钩是不现实的。然而,作者在其收集的数据中犯了两个关键错误:GDP 数据采用包含通胀的现价,而其全球物质使用数据是化石能源材料的总质量。严格来说,GDP 数据应采用不变价,以便随时间进行比较;经济体的物质投入应当是矿物原材料之和。对这些错误进行修正后,我们发现能源—GDP 相对脱钩的水平要小得多,而全球层面完全不存在物质—GDP 脱钩。我们通过加入1900—1990年的数据以提供更长的时间序列,来检验这些新结果,并发现全球物质使用相对脱钩始终处于较低水平,甚至没有脱钩。因此,关于物质的未来绝对脱钩不现实这一核心主张不仅仍然成立,而且经修正后的数据集进一步强化了该主张。

英文摘要:

The Ward et al. (2016) Plos-One paper is an important, heavily-cited paper in the decoupling literature. The authors present evidence of 1990-2015 growth in material and energy consumption and GDP at a world level, and for selected countries. They find only relative decoupling has occurred, leading to their central claim that future absolute decoupling is implausible. However, the authors have made two key errors in their collected data: GDP data is in current prices which includes inflation, and their global material use data is the total mass of fossil energy materials. Strictly, GDP data should be in constant prices to allow for its comparison over time, and material inputs to an economy should be the sum of mineral raw materials. Amending for these errors, we find much smaller levels of energy-GDP relative decoupling, and no materials-GDP decoupling at all at a global level. We check these new results by adding data for 1900-1990 to provide a longer time series, and find consistently low (and even no) levels of global relative decoupling of material use. The central claim for materials over the implausibility of future absolute decoupling therefore not only remains valid but is reinforced by the corrected datasets.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑