arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2401.11201cs.IRcs.AI
收藏

游走于微妙界限:考察搜索中的用户行为以检测参与效应与反噬效应

Navigating the Thin Line: Examining User Behavior in Search to Detect Engagement and Backfire Effects

Maastricht University(马斯特里赫特大学)

F. M. Cau, N. Tintarev

AI总结:

本文通过257人预注册实验研究有争议话题搜索中的偏误程度与AI立场标签,发现反态度偏误可增加对立内容消费但减少交互,立场标签在剔除未点击用户后可提升立场多样性。

摘要:

固执己见的用户往往会寻找与其既有信念一致的信息,同时由于确认偏误而忽视相互矛盾的证据。这种行为妨碍了他们在网络搜索时考虑替代立场的能力。尽管如此,很少有研究分析在有争议话题上搜索结果的多样化如何影响高度固执己见用户的搜索行为。为此,我们提出一项预注册用户研究(n = 257),考察不同水平(低和高)的偏误指标以及搜索结果呈现方式(带有或不带有 AI 预测立场标签)是否会影响固执己见用户在三个争议话题(即无神论、知识产权和校服)上的立场多样性消费与搜索行为。我们的结果表明,让参与者接触(反态度的)有偏搜索结果会增加他们对对立态度内容的消费,但我们也发现偏误与搜索页面内总体交互减少的趋势相关。我们还发现,19% 的用户与查询和搜索页面进行了交互,但没有选择任何搜索结果。当我们在事后分析中移除这些参与者后,发现立场标签提高了用户所消费立场的多样性,尤其是在搜索结果存在偏误时。我们的发现强调,未来研究有必要探索不同的搜索场景设置,以深入理解固执己见用户的行为。

英文摘要:

Opinionated users often seek information that aligns with their preexisting beliefs while dismissing contradictory evidence due to confirmation bias. This conduct hinders their ability to consider alternative stances when searching the web. Despite this, few studies have analyzed how the diversification of search results on disputed topics influences the search behavior of highly opinionated users. To this end, we present a preregistered user study (n = 257) investigating whether different levels (low and high) of bias metrics and search results presentation (with or without AI-predicted stances labels) can affect the stance diversity consumption and search behavior of opinionated users on three debated topics (i.e., atheism, intellectual property rights, and school uniforms). Our results show that exposing participants to (counter-attitudinally) biased search results increases their consumption of attitude-opposing content, but we also found that bias was associated with a trend toward overall fewer interactions within the search page. We also found that 19% of users interacted with queries and search pages but did not select any search results. When we removed these participants in a post-hoc analysis, we found that stance labels increased the diversity of stances consumed by users, particularly when the search results were biased. Our findings highlight the need for future research to explore distinct search scenario settings to gain insight into opinionated users' behavior.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑