arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2401.11100econ.GNq-fin.EC
收藏

印度儿童免疫接种计划对收入和消费支出的长期影响:评论

Long-term Effects of India's Childhood Immunization Program on Earnings and Consumption Expenditure: Comment

David Roodman

AI总结:

本文评论指出SNB(2023)关于印度UIP计划提高成年早期工资和支出的结论有误,其识别变异实际来自随访期时间推移而非政策错开引入,结果最好由通胀、经济增长和非随机调查顺序解释。

摘要:

Summan、Nandi和Bloom(2023),以下简称SNB,发现婴儿期暴露于印度的普及免疫接种计划(UIP)提高了成年早期的工资和家庭人均支出。SNB将这些结果对一个取决于出生年份和地区的处理指标进行回归,并控制了随访时的年龄。由于出生年份与年龄几乎共线,SNB的识别变异并非来自UIP的错开引入,而是来自随访期间时间的推移。在12个月的随访期内,较晚接受访谈的人更有可能接受了处理,并且平均报告了更高的工资和家庭支出。然而,在一个由年龄过大而无法在婴儿期暴露于UIP的人群组成的对照组中,工资和家庭支出的涨幅至少与处理组一样多。SNB的结果最好用随访调查期间的通货膨胀、经济增长和非随机调查顺序来解释。

英文摘要:

Summan, Nandi, and Bloom (2023), hereafter SNB, find that exposure during infancy to India's Universal Immunization Programme (UIP) increased wages and per-capita household expenditure in early adulthood. SNB regress these outcomes on a treatment indicator that depends upon year and district of birth while controlling for age at follow-up. Because year of birth and age are nearly collinear, SNB's identifying variation does not come from the staggered introduction of the UIP, but rather from the progression of time during the follow-up period. Within the 12-month follow-up period, those interviewed later were more likely to have been treated and, on average, reported higher wages and household expenditure. Wages and household expenditure, however, rose by at least as much in a control group composed of people too old to have been exposed as infants to the UIP as in the treated group. SNB's results are best explained by inflation, economic growth, and non-random survey sequencing during the follow-up survey period.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑