构思还是固着:示例对问题解决的影响随示例呈现界面设计而变化
Formulating or Fixating: Effects of Examples on Problem Solving Vary as a Function of Example Presentation Interface Design
AI总结:
通过182人实验比较不同示例呈现界面,发现列表式示例易导致固着并降低表现,而情境化示例有助于构建问题空间模型。
摘要:
促进示例接触的交互式系统可以提升问题解决表现。然而,此类系统的设计者往往面临许多关于用户将如何与示例交互的实际设计决策,却缺乏清晰的理论指导。为理解示例交互设计选择如何影响人们是否以及如何从示例中获益,我们开展了一项实验:182名参与者完成一项受控的探索性创造力任务类比任务,并可访问具有不同多样性的示例和不同的呈现界面。当示例以列表形式呈现时,任务表现比将示例置于探索空间中情境化呈现或通过下拉列表呈现时更差。示例列表与更强的固着相关,而情境化示例则与利用示例构建问题空间模型以指导探索相关。我们讨论了这些结果对一个理论框架的启示,该框架将设计选择映射到从示例中获得创造性灵感的基本心理机制。
英文摘要:
Interactive systems that facilitate exposure to examples can augment problem solving performance. However designers of such systems are often faced with many practical design decisions about how users will interact with examples, with little clear theoretical guidance. To understand how example interaction design choices affect whether/how people benefit from examples, we conducted an experiment where 182 participants worked on a controlled analog to an exploratory creativity task, with access to examples of varying diversity and presentation interfaces. Task performance was worse when examples were presented in a list, compared to contextualized in the exploration space or shown in a dropdown list. Example lists were associated with more fixation, whereas contextualized examples were associated with using examples to formulate a model of the problem space to guide exploration. We discuss implications of these results for a theoretical framework that maps design choices to fundamental psychological mechanisms of creative inspiration from examples.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。