论数学中的功绩与公平
On merit and equity in math
AI总结:
本文指出一篇用数据质疑美国数学科学精英统治的论文存在逻辑缺陷,其论证依赖未经检验且与自身数据矛盾的假设,因此结论无效。
摘要:
在最近一篇由一群有成就和/或有抱负的数学家撰写的论文《量化美国授予博士学位的数学科学系中的不平等并记录精英主义》(arXiv:2308.13750)中,作者利用数据来挑战“美国数学科学是精英统治”这一观念。我们表明,无论被挑战的观念是否有效,该论文中的论证都是无效的。也就是说,除了其他缺陷之外,他们依赖一种逻辑技巧:从一个作者未加检验(并且实际上与他们自己的数据相矛盾)的假设出发,断言由此得出的结论是有效的。
英文摘要:
In recent paper "Quantifying Inequities and Documenting Elitism in PhD-granting Mathematical Sciences Departments in the United States" (arXiv:2308.13750) by a group of accomplished and/or aspiring mathematicians, the authors use data to challenge ``the idea that the mathematical sciences in the United States is a meritocracy''. We show that, regardless of the validity of the challenged idea, the arguments in the paper are invalid. Namely, among other flaws, they rely on a logical trick of asserting the validity of the conclusion derived from an assumption which the authors neglect to test (and which actually contradicts their own data).
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。