arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2401.03554stat.MEstat.AP
收藏

虚假发现率与局部化能力

False Discovery Rate and Localizing Power

The University of Texas Rio Grande Valley(德克萨斯大学里奥格兰德河谷分校);University of Oxford(牛津大学);University of South Carolina(南卡罗来纳大学)

Anderson M. Winkler, Paul A. Taylor, Thomas E. Nichols, Chris Rorden

AI总结:

本文提出通过选择性推断和BKY方法改进FDR控制,以更准确地处理双尾检验中的方向性推断问题。

摘要:

虚假发现率(FDR)常用于神经影像学研究中的多重检验校正。然而,当使用双尾检验时,对结果进行方向性推断可能导致错误率大幅上升,甚至接近100%。这是因为FDR仅在所有检验上控制错误率,而不是在子集内,如仅在一个方向或另一个方向的检验中。本文考虑并评估了不同策略以控制此类情况下的FDR,使用合成和真实影像数据。将检验按假设检验的方向或检验统计量的方向分开的策略更有效地控制了方向性错误率并保留了FDR的优势,尽管在完全没有信号的情况下,错误风险翻倍。将检验合并在两个方向或使用简单双尾p值的策略可能导致无效的方向性结论,即使这些检验在全局上有效。解决此问题的方法是通过选择性推断,将正负尾视为集合(家族),然后进行局部筛选,再以修改后的FDR水平进行控制。此外,BKY程序可以替代广为人知的Benjamini-Hochberg方法,从而提供额外的功率。这些方法易于实现。最后,为了使方向性推断的阈值有效,我们建议影像软件应允许用户为统计图的两侧设置不对称阈值。尽管FDR仍然是多重检验校正的有效且强大的程序,但在双尾检验进行方向性推断或更广泛地进行任何局部推断时仍需谨慎。

英文摘要:

False discovery rate (FDR) is commonly used for correction for multiple testing in neuroimaging studies. However, when using two-tailed tests, making directional inferences about the results can lead to a vastly inflated error rate, even approaching 100% in some cases. This happens because FDR controls the error rate only globally, over all tests, not within subsets, such as among those in only one or another direction. Here we consider and evaluate different strategies for FDR control in such cases, using both synthetic and real imaging data. Approaches that separate the tests by direction of the hypothesis test, or by the direction of the resulting test statistic, more properly control the directional error rate and preserve FDR benefits, albeit with a doubled risk of errors under complete absence of signal. Strategies that combine tests in both directions, or that use simple two-tailed p-values, can lead to invalid directional conclusions, even if these tests remain globally valid. A solution to this problem is through the use of selective inference, whereby positive and negative tails are treated as sets (families), which are screened locally, then subjected to FDR at a modified level that controls average FDR over those that survive the initial screening. Moreover, the BKY procedure can be used in place of the well-known Benjamini-Hochberg, yielding additional power. These methods are easy to implement. Finally, to enable valid thresholding for directional inference, we suggest that imaging software should allow the user to set asymmetrical thresholds for the two sides of the statistical map. While FDR continues to be a valid, powerful procedure for multiple testing correction, care is needed when making directional inferences for two-tailed tests, or more broadly, when making any localized inference.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑