arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2401.01973stat.OTmath.HO
收藏

促进伦理推理融入量化课程:利益相关者分析、伦理实践标准与案例研究

Facilitating the Integration of Ethical Reasoning into Quantitative Courses: Stakeholder Analysis, Ethical Practice Standards, and Case Studies

Rochelle E. Tractenberg, Suzanne Thorton

AI总结:

本文针对量化课程中伦理教学易分散注意力、伦理实践不等同于研究伦理培训的问题,提出将利益相关者分析作为教学评估工具,以真实融入伦理推理与伦理实践标准,覆盖非研究方向的量化专业学生。

摘要:

案例研究通常用于教授“伦理学”,但在量化课程中引入案例分析,对教师和学习者而言都可能显得分散注意力。此外,案例分析通常聚焦于与人相关的问题:获取知情同意、与研究团队成员协作,以及/或者潜在的机构政策违规行为。尽管这些问题与部分研究相关,但并非所有量化课程的学生都打算成为研究者;而无论学习者是否计划从事研究,伦理实践都是数学、统计学、数据科学和计算机专业学生的核心议题。\n伦理推理是一种思维方式,要求个体评估自己对潜在伦理问题的认知(即前置知识),在某些情况下,还要评估自己观察到的、被要求执行的或已经实施的行为,与自己所认知的伦理行为之间存在何种偏差。伦理推理是一套可学习、可提升的知识、技能与能力集合,能帮助学习者认清自己对学科“伦理实践”构成要素的已知与未知部分,在某些情况下,还能促使他们思考替代性决策——如何先识别这类偏差,进而绕过或应对它们。\n利益相关者分析是前置知识的一部分,无论是否存在需要应对的实际案例或情境,都可以使用。在以量化内容为主的课程中,利益相关者分析是一种实用的教学与评估工具,既能用于融入真实的伦理内容,也能促进严谨的量化思考。将“伦理实践培训”与“负责任研究行为培训”等同起来是错误的。本文探讨了如何在量化课程中真实地引入伦理推理、利益相关者分析和伦理实践标准。

英文摘要:

Case studies are typically used to teach 'ethics', but in quantitative courses it can seem distracting, for both instructor and learner, to introduce a case analysis. Moreover, case analyses are typically focused on issues relating to people: obtaining consent, dealing with research team members, and/or potential institutional policy violations. While relevant to some research, not all students in quantitative courses plan to become researchers, and ethical practice is an essential topic for students of of mathematics, statistics, data science, and computing regardless of whether or not the learner intends to do research. Ethical reasoning is a way of thinking that requires the individual to assess what they know about a potential ethical problem (their prerequisite knowledge), and in some cases, how behaviors they observe, are directed to perform, or have performed, diverge from what they know to be ethical behavior. Ethical reasoning is a learnable, improvable set of knowledge, skills, and abilities that enable learners to recognize what they do and do not know about what constitutes 'ethical practice' of a discipline, and in some cases, to contemplate alternative decisions about how to first recognize, and then proceed past, or respond to, such divergences. A stakeholder analysis is part of prerequisite knowledge, and can be used whether there is or is not an actual case or situation to react to. In courses with mainly quantitative content, a stakeholder analysis is a useful tool for instruction and assessment. It can be used to both integrate authentic ethical content and encourage careful quantitative thought. It is a mistake to treat 'training in ethical practice' and 'training in responsible conduct of research' as the same thing. This paper discusses how to introduce ethical reasoning, stakeholder analysis, and ethical practice standards authentically in quantitative courses.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑