arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2401.00599physics.chem-phcs.LG
收藏

NMR相关与交换实验的子采样

Sub-sampling of NMR Correlation and Exchange Experiments

University of Cambridge(剑桥大学);Harvard Medical School(哈佛医学院);Martinos Centre for Biomedical Imaging, Massachusetts General Hospital(马萨诸塞总医院马蒂诺斯生物医学影像中心)

Julian B. B. Beckmann, Mick D. Mantle, Andrew J. Sederman, Lynn F. Gladden

AI总结:

研究子采样对NMR信号反演性能的影响,发现深度学习在完全或接近完全采样时优于正则化,而显著子采样时MTGV正则化更优,完全随机采样为最佳方案,且代价函数选择显著影响算法排名。

摘要:

将子采样应用于模拟的$T_1$-$D$ NMR信号,并评估其对反演性能的影响。为此,采用了不同级别的子采样,范围从完全采样信号到仅少于原始数据点的百分之二。这结合了多种采样方案,包括完全随机采样、截断以及两者的组合。为了比较不同反演算法的性能,使用Tikhonov正则化、改进的全变分广义正则化(MTGV)、深度学习以及深度学习与Tikhonov正则化的组合对生成的子采样信号进行反演。此外,还研究了所选代价函数对相对反演性能的影响。总体而言,可以证明在绝大多数情况下,如果信号完全或接近完全采样,深度学习明显优于基于正则化的反演方法。然而,在显著子采样的信号情况下,正则化产生比深度学习更好的反演性能,其中MTGV明显优于Tikhonov。此外,完全随机采样被确定为最佳的整体采样方案,与反演方法无关。最后,还表明代价函数的选择确实极大地影响测试反演算法的相对排名,突出了根据实验意图选择代价函数的重要性。

英文摘要:

Sub-sampling is applied to simulated $T_1$-$D$ NMR signals and its influence on inversion performance is evaluated. For this different levels of sub-sampling were employed ranging from the fully sampled signal down to only less than two percent of the original data points. This was combined with multiple sample schemes including fully random sampling, truncation and a combination of both. To compare the performance of different inversion algorithms, the so-generated sub-sampled signals were inverted using Tikhonov regularization, modified total generalized variation (MTGV) regularization, deep learning and a combination of deep learning and Tikhonov regularization. Further, the influence of the chosen cost function on the relative inversion performance was investigated. Overall, it could be shown that for a vast majority of instances, deep learning clearly outperforms regularization based inversion methods, if the signal is fully or close to fully sampled. However, in the case of significantly sub-sampled signals regularization yields better inversion performance than its deep learning counterpart with MTGV clearly prevailing over Tikhonov. Additionally, fully random sampling could be identified as the best overall sampling scheme independent of the inversion method. Finally, it could also be shown that the choice of cost function does vastly influence the relative rankings of the tested inversion algorithms highlighting the importance of choosing the cost function accordingly to experimental intentions.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑