arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2312.06309cs.LGstat.AP
收藏

一种评估问卷数据的无监督学习方法——从测量不变性违背中能学到什么

An unsupervised learning approach to evaluate questionnaire data -- what one can learn from violations of measurement invariance

Goethe-University Frankfurt(法兰克福大学)

Max Hahn-Klimroth, Paul W. Dierkes, Matthias W. Kleespies

AI总结:

针对缺乏测量不变性时问卷数据难以跨群体分析的问题,提出一种包含数据准备、聚类和相似度测量的三阶段无监督学习方法,能自然比较群体答题模式并将测量不变性违背转化为有意义的相似度度量。

摘要:

在社会科学和人文学科的多个分支中,基于标准化问卷的调查是突出的研究工具。尽管分析数据的方法多种多样,但一些标准程序已确立起来。当这些调查想要分析不同群体(如国家、性别、年龄等)的答题模式差异时,只有在存在测量不变性(即测量构念在各群体间具有心理测量等价性)的情况下,这些程序才能有意义地实施。正如 Sauerwein et al. (2021) 提出的一个开放问题所述,亟需能够在缺乏测量不变性时依然有效的新评估方法。本文提出了一种基于无监督学习的方法来处理此类研究数据,建议采用分三个阶段的程序:数据准备、问卷聚类,以及基于所得聚类和各群体属性测量相似度。我们在三个数据集中生成了合成数据,借此比较本文方法与 PCA 方法在满足测量不变性和违背测量不变性时的表现。主要结果表明,该方法提供了群体间的自然比较以及对各群体答题模式的自然描述。此外,即使缺乏测量不变性,它也能安全地应用于各种数据集。最后,该方法能将测量不变性(及其违背)转化为有意义的相似度度量。

英文摘要:

In several branches of the social sciences and humanities, surveys based on standardized questionnaires are a prominent research tool. While there are a variety of ways to analyze the data, some standard procedures have become established. When those surveys want to analyze differences in the answer patterns of different groups (e.g., countries, gender, age, ...), these procedures can only be carried out in a meaningful way if there is measurement invariance, i.e., the measured construct has psychometric equivalence across groups. As recently raised as an open problem by Sauerwein et al. (2021), new evaluation methods that work in the absence of measurement invariance are needed. This paper promotes an unsupervised learning-based approach to such research data by proposing a procedure that works in three phases: data preparation, clustering of questionnaires, and measuring similarity based on the obtained clustering and the properties of each group. We generate synthetic data in three data sets, which allows us to compare our approach with the PCA approach under measurement invariance and under violated measurement invariance. As a main result, we obtain that the approach provides a natural comparison between groups and a natural description of the response patterns of the groups. Moreover, it can be safely applied to a wide variety of data sets, even in the absence of measurement invariance. Finally, this approach allows us to translate (violations of) measurement invariance into a meaningful measure of similarity.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑