arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2312.02632cs.CYphysics.soc-ph
收藏

开放自行车基础设施数据质量如何?丹麦全国范围的案例研究

How Good Is Open Bicycle Infrastructure Data? A Countrywide Case Study of Denmark

Ane Rahbek Vierø, Anastassia Vybornova, Michael Szell

AI总结:

该研究针对丹麦自行车基础设施数据质量研究不足的问题,对比评估了OSM与GeoDanmark两大开放数据集的全国性数据质量,发现二者均有缺陷需融合,且农村地区完整性问题更突出,同时指出密度代理法的局限性并给出数据优化建议。

摘要:

骑行是丹麦交通系统实现可持续转型的关键要素。为提升骑行率,需要构建更完善的全国性自行车基础设施网络。规划这类网络需要高质量的基础设施数据,但目前自行车基础设施数据的质量研究严重不足。本文对丹麦两个最大的专用自行车基础设施开放数据集——OpenStreetMap(OSM,开放街图)和GeoDanmark开展了全国性数据质量评估,探究这些数据是否足以支撑基于网络的骑行条件分析。研究发现,两个数据集的质量均未达要求,必须进行数据集融合才能得到完整的数据集。我们对数据质量的空间差异分析表明,农村地区更易存在数据完整性问题。研究证实,将基础设施密度作为数据完整性代理指标的常用方法并不适用于自行车基础设施数据,因此需要通过匹配对应要素来评估数据完整性。基于本次数据质量评估,我们建议开展针对性的地图绘制工作以提升数据完整性,制定统一标准以增强不同数据源间的可比性,并更加关注数据拓扑结构以确保自行车网络数据的高质量。

英文摘要:

Cycling is a key ingredient for a sustainability shift of Denmark's transportation system. To increase cycling rates, a better nationwide network of bicycle infrastructure is required. Planning such a network requires high-quality infrastructure data, however, the quality of bicycle infrastructure data is severely understudied. Here, we compare Denmark's two largest open data sets on dedicated bicycle infrastructure, OpenStreetMap (OSM) and GeoDanmark, in a countrywide data quality assessment, asking whether data is good enough for network-based analysis of cycling conditions. We find that neither of the data sets is of sufficient quality, and that data set conflation is necessary to obtain a complete dataset. Our analysis of the spatial variation of data quality suggests that rural areas are more likely to suffer from problems with data completeness. We demonstrate that the prevalent method of using infrastructure density as a proxy for data completeness is not suitable for bicycle infrastructure data, and that matching of corresponding features thus is necessary to assess data completeness. Based on our data quality assessment we recommend strategic mapping efforts towards data completeness, consistent standards to support comparability between different data sources, and increased focus on data topology to ensure high-quality bicycle network data.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑