欧盟供应链尽职调查风险评估:用网络方法估算拟议欧盟指令的预期有效性
Supply Chain Due Diligence Risk Assessment for the EU: A Network Approach to estimate expected effectiveness of the planned EU directive
AI总结:
研究构建涵盖3000万家欧盟企业、9亿条供应链接的全尺度网络,评估CSDDD风险覆盖,发现三度小世界结构使多数企业在近层供应链面临劳工侵权风险,并建议监管从监控买卖链接转向监控供应商。
摘要:
全球化对我们所消费产品中蕴含的劳工标准产生了不良影响。本文提出对供应链尽职调查法规进行事前评估,例如欧盟《企业可持续尽职调查指令》(CSDDD)。我们基于3000万家欧盟企业的结构性商业统计数据构建了一个全尺度网络模型,以量化欧洲供应链中与可能涉及侵犯人权行为的企业存在联系的可能性。这些企业的9亿条供应链接以与多区域投入产出数据、欧盟进口数据以及企业层面生产网络的典型事实相一致的方式进行建模。我们发现该网络呈现出具有三度分离的小世界效应,这意味着大多数企业在网络中彼此相距不超过三步。因此,我们发现约8.5%的欧盟公司面临其供应链第一层存在童工或强迫劳动的风险,约82.4%的公司可能在第二层存在此类违规者,超过99.1%的公司在第三层存在此类违规者。我们还按国家、行业和规模对公司进行画像,分析其在供应链特定层级出现侵犯人权或童工及强迫劳动违规行为的可能性,揭示了欧盟公司之间存在显著的异质性。我们的结果表明,正如CSDDD目前所提议的那样,侧重于监控单个买方—供应商链接的供应链尽职调查法规可能无效,原因在于高度冗余,以及单个公司价值链无法与全球供应网络适当隔离。相反,为了在不损害尽职调查覆盖范围的情况下最大化成本效益,我们建议法规应侧重于监控单个供应商。
英文摘要:
Globalization has had undesirable effects on the labor standards embedded in the products we consume. This paper proposes an ex-ante evaluation of supply chain due diligence regulations, such as the EU Corporate Sustainable Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD). We construct a full-scale network model derived from structural business statistics of 30 million EU firms to quantify the likelihood of links to firms potentially involved in human rights abuses in the European supply chain. The 900 million supply links of these firms are modeled in a way that is consistent with multiregional input-output data, EU import data, and stylized facts of firm-level production networks. We find that this network exhibits a small world effect with three degrees of separation, meaning that most firms are no more than three steps away from each other in the network. Consequently we find that about 8.5% of EU companies are at risk of having child or forced labor in the first tier of their supply chains, about 82.4% are likely to have such offenders at the second tier and more than 99.1% have such offenders at the third tier. We also profile companies by country, sector, and size for the likelihood of having human rights violations or child and forced labor violations at a given tier in their supply chain, revealing considerable heterogeneity across EU companies. Our results show that supply chain due diligence regulations that focus on monitoring individual buyer-supplier links, as currently proposed in the CSDDD, are likely to be ineffective due to a high degree of redundancy and the fact that individual company value chains cannot be properly isolated from the global supply network. Rather, to maximize cost-effectiveness without compromising due diligence coverage, we suggest that regulations should focus on monitoring individual suppliers.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。