arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2311.04657stat.MEmath.STstat.TH
收藏

利用大量弱实验、代理变量与交叉折叠矩进行不完美代理下的长期因果推断

Long-Term Causal Inference with Imperfect Surrogates using Many Weak Experiments, Proxies, and Cross-Fold Moments

Aurélien Bibaut, Nathan Kallus, Simon Ejdemyr, Michael Zhao

AI总结:

针对短期替代指标推断长期因果效应时的替代悖论与弱实验偏差,提出基于交叉折叠矩(如JIVE)和代理变量的方法,构造有效置信区间并处理混杂与效应泄漏。

摘要:

利用短期替代指标推断对长期结果的因果效应,对于快速创新至关重要。然而,即使治疗是随机分配的,且替代指标完全中介了治疗对结果的效应,我们仍可能因替代指标与结果之间的混杂而错误判断因果效应的方向——这就是著名的“替代悖论”情形。大量历史实验的可得性,为将替代指标作为工具变量并绕过这种混杂提供了机会。但是,即便实验数量不断增加,如果每个实验的规模有界,两阶段最小二乘法仍具有不消失的偏差;而且当大多数实验几乎不能推动指标变化时(实践中正是如此),这种偏差会进一步加剧。我们展示了如何利用交叉折叠程序(JIVE即为其中一例)消除这一偏差,并在长期结果尚未观测到的新实验中,为长期效应构造有效的置信区间。我们的方法还允许对未被替代指标完全中介的效应进行代理,从而能够同时处理混杂和效应泄漏这两类对标准统计替代性条件的违背。

英文摘要:

Inferring causal effects on long-term outcomes using short-term surrogates is crucial to rapid innovation. However, even when treatments are randomized and surrogates fully mediate their effect on outcomes, it's possible that we get the direction of causal effects wrong due to confounding between surrogates and outcomes -- a situation famously known as the surrogate paradox. The availability of many historical experiments offer the opportunity to instrument for the surrogate and bypass this confounding. However, even as the number of experiments grows, two-stage least squares has non-vanishing bias if each experiment has a bounded size, and this bias is exacerbated when most experiments barely move metrics, as occurs in practice. We show how to eliminate this bias using cross-fold procedures, JIVE being one example, and construct valid confidence intervals for the long-term effect in new experiments where long-term outcome has not yet been observed. Our methodology further allows to proxy for effects not perfectly mediated by the surrogates, allowing us to handle both confounding and effect leakage as violations of standard statistical surrogacy conditions.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑