arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2310.16059physics.soc-ph
收藏

PubPeer与科学的自我纠错:男性主导的出版物更容易被撤稿

PubPeer and Self-Correction of Science: Male-Led Publications More Prone to Retraction

Abdelghani Maddi, Emmanuel Monneau, Catherine Guaspare, Floriana Gargiulo, Michel Dubois

AI总结:

本研究分析了PubPeer上93,563篇出版物,发现男性主导或全男性撰写的论文撤稿率比全女性高出20%至29%,且作者数量与撤稿率呈反比。

摘要:

本文具有双重目标。首先,旨在调查在PubPeer上被评论的出版物中,性别多样性是否对这些出版物的(未)撤稿产生影响。其次,寻求分析撤稿的原因,并考察基于男女合作的撤稿是否存在差异。为此,本研究使用了2012年至2021年间在PubPeer上讨论的93,563篇出版物样本。结果显示,在被评论的出版物中,5%(4,513篇)被撤稿。集中指数和回归结果表明,完全由男性撰写或由男性作者主导的出版物,与完全由女性撰写的出版物相比,被撤稿的可能性高出20%至29%。关于撤稿原因,结果表明,无论性别如何,作者在独立工作时更容易参与虚假同行评审或剽窃等活动。女性更多集中在图像篡改和数据错误上,而男性更多涉及文章重复。此外,结果表明作者人数与撤稿之间存在反比关系,这表明作者数量较多可能有助于更好地控制出版物并减少不端行为的诱惑。

英文摘要:

This article has a dual objective. Firstly, it aims to investigate whether gender diversity in publications reviewed on Pubpeer has an impact on the (non)retraction of those publications. Secondly, it seeks to analyze the reasons for retractions and examine if there are disparities in retractions based on male-female collaborations. To achieve this, the study utilized a sample of 93,563 publications discussed on Pubpeer spanning the period from 2012 to 2021. The findings reveal that among the reviewed publications, 5% (4,513) were retracted. The concentration index and regression results indicate that publications authored solely by men or led by male authors are 20% to 29% more likely to be retracted compared to those authored solely by women. Regarding the reasons for retractions, the results show that regardless of gender, authors, when working alone, are more prone to engaging in activities such as fake peer review or plagiarism. Women are more concentrated in image manipulation and data errors, while men are more involved in article duplication. Furthermore, the results demonstrate an inverse relationship between the number of authors and retractions, suggesting that a higher number of authors may facilitate better publication control and reduce the temptation for misconduct.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑