撤稿对作者合作网络的涟漪效应
The Ripple Effect of Retraction on an Author's Collaboration Network
AI总结:
本研究基于含5972篇撤稿论文、24209位作者的数据集,探究撤稿对作者合作网络的影响,发现有撤稿记录作者的合作网络结构相较无撤稿作者无显著变化,污名化对其合作网络影响很小,对机构推行学术伦理措施有参考价值。
摘要:
涉及科学不端行为的科学家可能面临社会污名化,进而导致孤立与合作机会受限。每个个体的声誉都会投射到团队上,因为任何成员的学术造假行为都会影响团队声誉。此前的研究指出了引用惩罚对共同作者既往工作的影响、撤稿对共同作者研究生涯的影响,以及仅因关联就产生的污名化效应。本文探究了遭遇撤稿的作者及其职业生涯中从未有过撤稿记录的“无辜共同作者”的合作网络的形成与动态变化。我们利用包含5972篇撤稿论文、涉及24209位作者的数据集,研究了学术不端行为是否会削弱有不端行为作者的合作联结——与从未被指控学术不端的作者相比。我们观察到,与“无辜共同作者”的网络结构相比,涉及撤稿的作者的网络结构多年来并未发生显著变化。我们的结果表明,污名化很少会影响被污名化作者的合作网络。这些发现对采取严格措施、培育符合伦理规范的研究实践的机构具有参考意义。
英文摘要:
Scientists involved in scientific misconduct may face social stigmatization, leading to isolation and limited opportunities for collaboration. The reputation of every individual is reflected on the team, as the fraud attempted by any member will be reflected on the team. Earlier studies pointed out the impact of citation penalty on the prior work of coauthors, the effect of retraction on a co-author's research career, and stigmatization through mere association. This paper explores the formation and dynamics of the networks of authors who faced retractions and their "innocent coauthors" who never faced retractions in their careers. Leveraging a dataset of 5972 retracted papers involving 24209 authors, we investigate whether scientific misconduct reduces collaborative ties of misconducting authors as opposed to those who never faced allegations of academic misconduct. We observe that the network structure of authors involved in retractions does not change significantly over the years compared to that of the "innocent coauthors". Our results suggest that stigmatization rarely affects the collaboration network of stigmatized authors. Our findings have implications for institutions adopting stringent measures and fostering ethical practices research.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。