arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2310.02432cs.HCcs.SE
收藏

超越暗黑模式:一种基于概念的道德软件设计框架

Beyond Dark Patterns: A Concept-Based Framework for Ethical Software Design

Evan Caragay, Katherine Xiong, Jonathan Zong, Daniel Jackson

AI总结:

针对暗黑模式研究只说明“不应做什么”的问题,本文提出基于概念与积极预期行为的道德软件设计框架,并通过三项研究验证其描述、评估和记录能力。

摘要:

当前的暗黑模式研究告诉设计者不应做什么,但他们如何知道应该做什么?与以往聚焦于应避免的模式及其底层原则的方法不同,我们提出了一个以积极预期行为为基础的框架,可据此判断各种偏差。为阐明这种预期行为,我们使用概念——构成应用程序的抽象功能单元。我们将某种设计定义为暗黑模式:当其概念违背用户预期,并以损害用户利益为代价使应用程序提供者获益。尽管用户预期可能存在差异,但当用户在多个应用程序中遇到相同概念时,往往会形成共同预期,我们可以在概念目录中将其记录为标准概念。我们通过三项研究评估了该框架和概念目录,展示了它们描述现有暗黑模式、评估细微设计以及记录常见应用程序功能的能力。

英文摘要:

Current dark pattern research tells designers what not to do, but how do they know what to do? In contrast to prior approaches that focus on patterns to avoid and their underlying principles, we present a framework grounded in positive expected behavior against which deviations can be judged. To articulate this expected behavior, we use concepts -- abstract units of functionality that compose applications. We define a design as dark when its concepts violate users' expectations, and benefit the application provider at the user's expense. Though user expectations can differ, users tend to develop common expectations as they encounter the same concepts across multiple applications, which we can record in a concept catalog as standard concepts. We evaluate our framework and concept catalog through three studies, illustrating their ability to describe existing dark patterns, evaluate nuanced designs, and document common application functionality.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑