论物联网网络安全指南的内容与效用
On the Contents and Utility of IoT Cybersecurity Guidelines
AI总结:
通过定性分析25份物联网安全指南中的958条建议,研究发现单一指南在覆盖广度和深度上存在不足,但指南整体能缓解主要安全问题,且87.2%的建议具有可操作性。
摘要:
物联网设备和基础设施的网络安全问题日益严重。作为回应,全球各组织发布了物联网安全指南,通过提供关于物联网系统开发和运营的建议来保护其公民和客户。尽管这些指南正在被采用(例如被美国联邦承包商采用),但其内容和价值尚未得到批判性审查。具体而言,我们不知道它们涵盖了哪些主题和建议,以及在防止现实世界物联网故障方面的有效性。在本文中,我们通过对指南的定性研究来填补这些空白。我们收集了142份物联网网络安全指南,并对其中的建议进行抽样,直到达到25份指南的饱和点。从得到的958条独特建议中,我们遵循扎根理论编码原则迭代开发了层次分类法,并研究了指南的全面性。此外,我们评估了每条建议的可操作性和具体性,并将建议与它们能够防止的CVE和新闻报道中的安全故障进行了匹配。我们报告称:(1)每份指南在主题覆盖和全面性上均存在不足;(2)87.2%的建议具有可操作性,38.7%的建议能够预防特定威胁;(3)尽管指南的集合缓解了我们新闻报道语料库中全部17起故障,但21%的CVE规避了这些指南。总之,我们报告了每份指南在深度和广度上的缺陷,但作为一个整体,它们解决了主要的安全问题。
英文摘要:
Cybersecurity concerns of Internet of Things (IoT) devices and infrastructure are growing each year. In response, organizations worldwide have published IoT security guidelines to protect their citizens and customers by providing recommendations on the development and operation of IoT systems. While these guidelines are being adopted, e.g. by US federal contractors, their content and merits have not been critically examined. Specifically, we do not know what topics and recommendations they cover and their effectiveness at preventing real-world IoT failures. In this paper, we address these gaps through a qualitative study of guidelines. We collect 142 IoT cybersecurity guidelines and sample them for recommendations until reaching saturation at 25 guidelines. From the resulting 958 unique recommendations, we iteratively develop a hierarchical taxonomy following grounded theory coding principles and study the guidelines' comprehensiveness. In addition, we evaluate the actionability and specificity of each recommendation and match recommendations to CVEs and security failures in the news they can prevent. We report that: (1) Each guideline has gaps in its topic coverage and comprehensiveness; (2) 87.2% recommendations are actionable and 38.7% recommendations can prevent specific threats; and (3) although the union of the guidelines mitigates all 17 of the failures from our news stories corpus, 21% of the CVEs evade the guidelines. In summary, we report shortcomings in each guideline's depth and breadth, but as a whole they address major security issues.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。