arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2310.01562q-bio.GNq-bio.QM
收藏

突变特征拟合工具的综合比较

A comprehensive comparison of tools for fitting mutational signatures

Matúš Medo, Charlotte K. Y. Ng, Michaela Medová

AI总结:

本文针对已知突变特征拟合工具缺乏系统基准的问题,评估十二款工具在八种癌症类型合成及真实突变目录上的表现,给出不同突变负荷下的最佳选择并指出参考特征约束与缺失特征的影响。

摘要:

突变特征将基因组中的特征性突变模式与癌症中发生的生物学或化学过程联系起来。突变特征分析有助于阐明肿瘤演化、预后和治疗策略。尽管从头提取突变特征的工具已经得到广泛基准测试,但将已知突变特征拟合到给定突变目录的工具仍缺乏类似评估。我们填补了这一空白:在具有对应八种癌症类型、由经验驱动的特征权重的合成突变目录上,综合评估了十二个特征拟合工具。平均而言,SigProfilerSingleSample 和 SigProfilerAssignment/MuSiCal 分别在每样本突变数较少和较多时表现最佳。我们进一步表明,临时性约束参考特征列表很可能产生较差结果。对真实突变目录的评估表明,参考目录中缺失特征的活性会给所有受评估工具带来相当大的问题。

英文摘要:

Mutational signatures connect characteristic mutational patterns in the genome with biological or chemical processes that take place in cancers. Analysis of mutational signatures can help elucidate tumor evolution, prognosis, and therapeutic strategies. Although tools for extracting mutational signatures de novo have been extensively benchmarked, a similar effort is lacking for tools that fit known mutational signatures to a given catalog of mutations. We fill this gap by comprehensively evaluating twelve signature fitting tools on synthetic mutational catalogs with empirically-driven signature weights corresponding to eight cancer types. On average, SigProfilerSingleSample and SigProfilerAssignment/MuSiCal perform best for small and large numbers of mutations per sample, respectively. We further show that ad hoc constraining the list of reference signatures is likely to produce inferior results. Evaluation of real mutational catalogs suggests that the activity of signatures that are absent in the reference catalog poses considerable problems to all evaluated tools.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑