概率概念、统计学危机与 Bayesing 难以承受之轻
The concept of probability, crisis in statistics, and the unbearable lightness of Bayesing
AI总结:
本文剖析统计学危机源于概率概念混淆,主张以 Kolmogorov 概率模型及其适用条件为科学基础,限定 Bayesian 分析的启发作用并结合多种分析与实验。
摘要:
统计学教育、统计学在科学研究中的应用,以及统计学本身作为一门科学学科,都处于危机之中。在科学内部,这场危机的主要原因是概率概念尚未得到充分澄清。本文旨在将具有科学基础的概率概念与其他不具备这一特征的概念区分开来。具有科学基础的概率概念是 Kolmogorov 的概率模型概念及其适用条件。Bayesian 统计学建立在主观概率概念之上,因此在探寻真理时只能具有启发价值,但它不能也绝不应取代真理。走出危机的途径应当把 Kolmogorov 分析和 Bayesian 分析作为两个要素,二者各自都有明确定义且有限的用途。只有与定性分析和其他类型的定量分析相结合,并同实验结合起来,它们才能有助于得出正确结论。
英文摘要:
Education in statistics, the application of statistics in scientific research, and statistics itself as a scientific discipline are in crisis. Within science, the main cause of the crisis is the insufficiently clarified concept of probability. This article aims to separate the concept of probability which is scientifically based from other concepts that do not have this characteristic. The scientifically based concept of probability is Kolmogorovs concept of probability models together with the conditions of their applicability. Bayesian statistics is based on the subjective concept of probability, and as such can only have a heuristic value in searching for the truth, but it cannot and must not replace the truth. The way out of the crisis should take Kolmogorov and Bayesian analysis as elements, each of which has a well-defined and limited use. Only together with qualitative analysis and other types of quantitative analysis, and combined with experiments, they can contribute to reaching correct conclusions.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。