生命科学中可复现的领域特定知识图谱:一项系统性文献综述
Reproducible Domain-Specific Knowledge Graphs in the Life Sciences: a Systematic Literature Review
AI总结:
本文系统综述了生命科学等领域特定知识图谱的可复现性,发现250个图谱中仅8个公开源代码、1个通过评估,揭示可复现性严重不足并呼吁加强研究与实践转变。
摘要:
知识图谱(KGs)被广泛用于表示和组织不同领域中的结构化知识。然而,知识图谱的创建和维护带来了巨大挑战。开发一个知识图谱需要在数据建模、本体设计和数据管理方面具备广泛的专业知识。此外,知识图谱是动态的,需要持续更新和质量控制,以确保准确性和相关性。这些复杂性导致其开发和维护需要付出相当大的努力。知识图谱中值得关注的一个关键维度是可复现性。复制和验证知识图谱的能力对于确保其所代表知识的可信度和可持续性至关重要。可复现的知识图谱不仅通过允许其他人在现有知识基础上继续研究来支持开放科学,而且还能提高信息传播的透明度和可靠性。尽管领域特定知识图谱的数量不断增加,但一直缺乏针对其可复现性的全面分析。本文通过提供领域特定知识图谱的总体概览,并根据各种可复现性标准对其进行比较,从而弥补了这一空白。我们对19个不同领域的研究表明,在250个领域特定知识图谱中,只有8个(3.2%)提供了公开可用的源代码。其中,只有一个系统能够成功通过我们的可复现性评估(14.3%)。这些发现凸显了在不同领域的知识图谱中实现可复现性所面临的挑战和差距。我们发现,已发表的领域特定知识图谱中只有0.4%是可复现的,这表明显然需要进一步的研究和文化实践的转变。
英文摘要:
Knowledge graphs (KGs) are widely used for representing and organizing structured knowledge in diverse domains. However, the creation and upkeep of KGs pose substantial challenges. Developing a KG demands extensive expertise in data modeling, ontology design, and data curation. Furthermore, KGs are dynamic, requiring continuous updates and quality control to ensure accuracy and relevance. These intricacies contribute to the considerable effort required for their development and maintenance. One critical dimension of KGs that warrants attention is reproducibility. The ability to replicate and validate KGs is fundamental for ensuring the trustworthiness and sustainability of the knowledge they represent. Reproducible KGs not only support open science by allowing others to build upon existing knowledge but also enhance transparency and reliability in disseminating information. Despite the growing number of domain-specific KGs, a comprehensive analysis concerning their reproducibility has been lacking. This paper addresses this gap by offering a general overview of domain-specific KGs and comparing them based on various reproducibility criteria. Our study over 19 different domains shows only eight out of 250 domain-specific KGs (3.2%) provide publicly available source code. Among these, only one system could successfully pass our reproducibility assessment (14.3%). These findings highlight the challenges and gaps in achieving reproducibility across domain-specific KGs. Our finding that only 0.4% of published domain-specific KGs are reproducible shows a clear need for further research and a shift in cultural practices.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。