arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2309.04833cs.CR
收藏

GitHub 安全干预措施的有效性

The Effectiveness of Security Interventions on GitHub

Felix Fischer, Jonas Höbenreich, Jens Grossklags

AI总结:

本文通过对5万多个GitHub仓库的安全相关提交进行时间序列分析,比较安全警报、安全更新和代码扫描三类干预的因果效应,并提炼有效设计要素与改进建议。

摘要:

2017年,GitHub成为首个向用户展示安全警报的在线开源平台。此后,它又推出了进一步的安全干预措施,以帮助开发者提升其开源软件的安全性。在本研究中,我们调查并比较了这些干预措施的效果。这为软件开发背景下的安全干预提供了宝贵的实证视角,并以大量数据驱动的洞见丰富了以定性和调查为主的文献格局。我们对涵盖超过50,000个GitHub仓库的大规模样本完整历史中、会改变安全性的提交进行时间序列分析,以推断安全警报、安全更新和代码扫描干预措施的因果效应。我们的分析表明,尽管GitHub的所有安全干预措施都对安全性具有显著的正向影响,但它们的效应大小差异很大。通过比较每项干预措施的设计,我们识别出了哪些构成要素运作良好、哪些则不然。我们还就从业者应如何改进其干预措施设计以提升有效性提供了建议。

英文摘要:

In 2017, GitHub was the first online open source platform to show security alerts to its users. It has since introduced further security interventions to help developers improve the security of their open source software. In this study, we investigate and compare the effects of these interventions. This offers a valuable empirical perspective on security interventions in the context of software development, enriching the predominantly qualitative and survey-based literature landscape with substantial data-driven insights. We conduct a time series analysis on security-altering commits covering the entire history of a large-scale sample of over 50,000 GitHub repositories to infer the causal effects of the security alert, security update, and code scanning interventions. Our analysis shows that while all of GitHub's security interventions have a significant positive effect on security, they differ greatly in their effect size. By comparing the design of each intervention, we identify the building blocks that worked well and those that did not. We also provide recommendations on how practitioners can improve the design of their interventions to enhance their effectiveness.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑