arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2309.02469physics.hist-ph
收藏

简单的无穷小部分能否解决芝诺的度量悖论?

Do Simple Infinitesimal Parts Solve Zeno's Paradox of Measure?

Lu Chen

AI总结:

本文提出无穷小原子论以回应芝诺度量悖论,该观点基于非标准分析并满足可加性,但面临不可测区域和外尔铺砖论证问题,无明显优势。

摘要:

我发展了一种关于空间结构的新观点——称为无穷小原子论——作为对芝诺度量悖论的回应。根据这一观点,空间由具有无穷小大小的终极部分组成,其中无穷小在罗宾逊的非标准分析框架内被理解。值得注意的是,这一观点满足一种可加性版本:对于每个有大小(尺寸)的区域,其大小等于其不相交部分的大小之和。特别是,有限区域的大小等于其无穷小部分的大小之和。尽管这一观点是对芝诺悖论的一种连贯方法,并且优于斯凯尔姆斯(1983)的无穷小方法,但它既面临标准观点的主要问题(不可测区域问题),也面临有限原子论的主要问题(外尔的铺砖论证),使其与这些熟悉的替代方案相比没有明显优势。

英文摘要:

I develop a new view of the structure of space--called infinitesimal atomism--as a reply to Zeno's paradox of measure. According to this view, space is composed of ultimate parts with infinitesimal size, where infinitesimals are understood within the framework of Robinson's nonstandard analysis. Notably, this view satisfies a version of additivity: for every region that has a size, its size is the sum of the sizes of its disjoint parts. In particular, the size of a finite region is the sum of the sizes of its infinitesimal parts. Although this view is a coherent approach to Zeno's paradox and is preferable to Skyrms's (1983) infinitesimal approach, it faces both the main problem for the standard view (the problem of unmeasurable regions) and the main problem for finite atomism (Weyl's tile argument), leaving it with no clear advantage over these familiar alternatives.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑