成功的研究者是否达到自组织临界点?
Do Successful Researchers Reach the Self-Organized Critical Point?
AI总结:
本文通过分析三十位科学家的被引统计,发现非常成功者的基尼指数和加尔各答指数会接近并围绕0.82波动,表明其发表统计达到自组织临界状态,而较低值满足线性关系k=1/2+0.39g。
摘要:
研究者的成功指数如今大多使用赫希指数($h$)来衡量。我们最近精确地证明,统计上 $h \sim \sqrt{N_c} \sim \sqrt{N_p}$,其中 $N_p$ 和 $N_c$ 分别表示研究者的总发表数和总被引数,这表明每篇论文的平均被引数($N_c/N_p$)以及因此得到的 $h$ 都是统计数(邓巴数),取决于研究者所属的共同体或网络。我们在此扩展早先的观察并表明,成功的迹象并不由总被引数 $N_c$ 反映,而是由各篇发表之间的被引不平等性反映。具体而言,我们表明,对于非常成功的作者,基尼指数($g$,给出各篇发表被引的平均不平等性)和加尔各答指数($k$,给出被引量最高的 $1 - k$ 比例的发表所获得的总被引比例;$k = 0.80$ 对应帕累托 80/20 定律)的年度变化会彼此接近到 $g = k \simeq 0.82$,这标志着其发表统计进入(或离开)自组织临界(SOC)状态的前兆。通过分析三十位成功科学家在其有记录的整个发表历史中的被引统计(来自 Google Scholar),我们发现其中非常成功者(大多是诺贝尔奖得主、斯坦福最高排名 Cite-Scorer 以及少数其他人)的 $g$ 和 $k$ 会达到并在该 $g = k \simeq 0.82$ 标记附近徘徊(先略高于、随后低于该标记),而其他人的 $g$ 和 $k$ 则始终低于该标记。我们还发现,所有低于(SOC 标记 0.82)的 $k$ 和 $g$ 值都符合线性关系 $k = 1/2 + cg$,其中 $c = 0.39$。
英文摘要:
The index of success of the researchers is now mostly measured using the Hirsch index ($h$). Our recent precise demonstration, that statistically $h \sim \sqrt {N_c} \sim \sqrt {N_p}$, where $N_p$ and $N_c$ denote respectively the total number of publications and total citations for the researcher, suggests that average number of citations per paper ($N_c/N_p$), and hence $h$, are statistical numbers (Dunbar numbers) depending on the community or network to which the researcher belongs. We show here, extending our earlier observations, that the indications of success are not reflected by the total citations $N_c$, rather by the inequalities among citations from publications to publications. Specifically, we show that for very successful authors, the yearly variations in the Gini index ($g$, giving the average inequality of citations for the publications) and the Kolkata index ($k$, giving the fraction of total citations received by the top $1 - k$ fraction of publications; $k = 0.80$ corresponds to Pareto's 80/20 law) approach each other to $g = k \simeq 0.82$, signaling a precursor for the arrival of (or departure from) the Self-Organized Critical (SOC) state of his/her publication statistics. Analyzing the citation statistics (from Google Scholar) of thirty successful scientists throughout their recorded publication history, we find that the $g$ and $k$ for very successful among them (mostly Nobel Laureates, highest rank Stanford Cite-Scorers, and a few others) reach and hover just above (and then) below that $g = k \simeq 0.82$ mark, while for others they remain below that mark. We also find that all the lower (than the SOC mark 0.82) values of $k$ and $g$ fit a linear relationship $k = 1/2 + cg$, with $c = 0.39$.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。