arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2308.07635cs.CLcs.AI

LLM-Mini-CEX:大型语言模型诊断对话的自动评估

LLM-Mini-CEX: Automatic Evaluation of Large Language Model for Diagnostic Conversation

Shanghai AI Lab(上海人工智能实验室);Zhejiang University(浙江大学);East China University of Science and Technology(华东理工大学)

Xiaoming Shi, Jie Xu, Jinru Ding, Jiali Pang, Sichen Liu, Shuqing Luo, Xingwei Peng, Lu Lu, Haihong Yang, Mingtao Hu, Tong Ruan, Shaoting Zhang

AI总结:

针对医疗 LLM 诊断对话缺乏统一评估且交互、人工评审成本高的问题,本文提出 LLM-specific Mini-CEX 标准,结合患者模拟器与 ChatGPT 实现自动化、可复现评估。

摘要:

人们越来越关注开发用于医疗诊断的 LLM,以提高诊断效率。尽管其技术潜力诱人,但目前缺乏统一且全面的评估标准,导致无法评估医疗 LLM 的质量和潜在风险,进而阻碍 LLM 在医疗场景中的应用。此外,当前评估严重依赖劳动密集型的 LLM 交互来获取诊断对话,并依赖人工评估诊断对话质量。为解决统一、全面评估标准缺失的问题,我们首先在原始 Mini-CEX 的基础上,初步建立了一个称为 LLM-specific Mini-CEX 的评估标准,以有效评估 LLM 的诊断能力。为解决劳动密集型交互问题,我们开发了一个患者模拟器,与 LLM 进行自动对话,并利用 ChatGPT 自动评估诊断对话。实验结果表明,LLM-specific Mini-CEX 足以且有必要用于评估医疗诊断对话。此外,在人文素养指标上,ChatGPT 可以替代人工评估,并在不同 LLM 之间提供可复现、自动化的比较。

英文摘要:

There is an increasing interest in developing LLMs for medical diagnosis to improve diagnosis efficiency. Despite their alluring technological potential, there is no unified and comprehensive evaluation criterion, leading to the inability to evaluate the quality and potential risks of medical LLMs, further hindering the application of LLMs in medical treatment scenarios. Besides, current evaluations heavily rely on labor-intensive interactions with LLMs to obtain diagnostic dialogues and human evaluation on the quality of diagnosis dialogue. To tackle the lack of unified and comprehensive evaluation criterion, we first initially establish an evaluation criterion, termed LLM-specific Mini-CEX to assess the diagnostic capabilities of LLMs effectively, based on original Mini-CEX. To address the labor-intensive interaction problem, we develop a patient simulator to engage in automatic conversations with LLMs, and utilize ChatGPT for evaluating diagnosis dialogues automatically. Experimental results show that the LLM-specific Mini-CEX is adequate and necessary to evaluate medical diagnosis dialogue. Besides, ChatGPT can replace manual evaluation on the metrics of humanistic qualities and provides reproducible and automated comparisons between different LLMs.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑