arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2307.07111cs.SE
收藏

不止于反应:调查 Emoji 反应在 GitHub Pull Requests 中的作用

More Than React: Investigating The Role of Emoji Reaction in GitHub Pull Requests

Dong Wang, Tao Xiao, Teyon Son, Raula Gaikovina Kula, Takashi Ishio, Yasutaka Kamei, Kenichi Matsumoto

AI总结:

本文通过挖掘七种语言的1,850个活跃仓库和365,811个 PR,实证分析 emoji 反应与审查时间、贡献者类型、评论意图及情感一致性的关系,证明其有助于协作沟通。

摘要:

开源软件开发已变得更具社交性和协作性,GitHub 就是明显例证。自2016年以来,GitHub 开始支持 emoji 反应等更非正式的方式,目标是在审查对仓库的任何代码变更时减少评论噪音。从代码审查语境来看,emoji 反应在多大程度上促进了更高效的审查过程仍属未知。我们开展了一项实证研究,挖掘七种流行语言中的1,850个活跃仓库,分析365,811个 Pull Requests(PRs)的 emoji 反应,并考察其与审查时间、首次贡献者、评论意图和情感一致性的关系。围绕这四个研究视角,我们首先发现 emoji 反应数量与审查时间存在显著相关性。其次,结果表明,首次贡献者提交的 PR 较不可能收到 emoji 反应。第三,结果揭示,具有信息提供意图的评论更可能收到 emoji 反应。第四,我们观察到评论与 emoji 反应之间情感不一致的情况只占很小比例,即识别出11.8%的实例。在这些情况下,普遍原因是审查者鼓励承认错误(即 acknowledge a mistake)的作者。除减少评论噪音外,我们的工作表明,emoji 反应在促进审查过程中的协作沟通方面发挥着积极作用。

英文摘要:

Open source software development has become more social and collaborative, evident GitHub. Since 2016, GitHub started to support more informal methods such as emoji reactions, with the goal to reduce commenting noise when reviewing any code changes to a repository. From a code review context, the extent to which emoji reactions facilitate a more efficient review process is unknown. We conduct an empirical study to mine 1,850 active repositories across seven popular languages to analyze 365,811 Pull Requests (PRs) for their emoji reactions against the review time, first-time contributors, comment intentions, and the consistency of the sentiments. Answering these four research perspectives, we first find that the number of emoji reactions has a significant correlation with the review time. Second, our results show that a PR submitted by a first-time contributor is less likely to receive emoji reactions. Third, the results reveal that the comments with an intention of information giving, are more likely to receive an emoji reaction. Fourth, we observe that only a small proportion of sentiments are not consistent between comments and emoji reactions, i.e., with 11.8% of instances being identified. In these cases, the prevalent reason is when reviewers cheer up authors that admit to a mistake, i.e., acknowledge a mistake. Apart from reducing commenting noise, our work suggests that emoji reactions play a positive role in facilitating collaborative communication during the review process.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑