本文介绍了一种从专家处引出先验分布的新方法。该方法对专家的决策过程进行建模,以推断罕见事件 A 的先验概率分布。更具体地说,假设存在一个与 A 密切相关的决策过程,该过程形成决策 Y,并且已经收集了决策历史。通过使用贝叶斯模型对作出历史决策时所观察到的数据进行建模,分析师可以推断随机变量 Y 的参数分布。该分布可用于近似事件 A 对应随机变量参数的先验分布。该方法在先验引出领域具有新颖性,并有可能改进现有方法,因为它利用了可能带来现实后果的真实决策过程,而且不要求专家具备统计学知识。由于该方法能够凸显影响决策过程的变量,因此可用于改进未来的决策。文中还通过一个为个体引出累犯率先验分布的应用,进一步解释了该方法。
英文摘要:
This article introduces a new method for eliciting prior distributions from experts. The method models an expert decision-making process to infer a prior probability distribution for a rare event $A$. More specifically, assuming there exists a decision-making process closely related to $A$ which forms a decision $Y$, where a history of decisions have been collected. By modelling the data observed to make the historic decisions, using a Bayesian model, an analyst can infer a distribution for the parameters of the random variable $Y$. This distribution can be used to approximate the prior distribution for the parameters of the random variable for event $A$. This method is novel in the field of prior elicitation and has the potential of improving upon current methods by using real-life decision-making processes, that can carry real-life consequences, and, because it does not require an expert to have statistical knowledge. Future decision making can be improved upon using this method, as it highlights variables that are impacting the decision making process. An application for eliciting a prior distribution of recidivism, for an individual, is used to explain this method further.
Bayesian joint modelling using semiparametric accelerated failure time approaches
The University of Queensland’s Clinical Trials Capability (ULTRA)(昆士兰大学临床试验能力中心(ULTRA));NHMRC Clinical Trial Centre, University of Sydney(悉尼大学国家健康与医学研究委员会临床试验中心);Australian and New Zealand Urogenital and Prostate (ANZUP) Cancer Trials Group(澳大利亚和新西兰泌尿生殖和前列腺癌症试验组)
Modelling disease progression with multi-level electronic health records data and informative observation times: an application to treating iron deficiency anaemia in primary care of the UK
Exploring dependence between categorical variables: benefits and limitations of using variable selection within Bayesian clustering in relation to log-linear modelling with interaction terms