arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2307.06571cs.SIcs.CY
收藏

解析极化:在线互动符号网络中的对立与对齐

Unpacking polarization: Antagonism and Alignment in Signed Networks of Online Interaction

Emma Fraxanet, Max Pellert, Simon Schweighofer, Vicenç Gómez, David Garcia

AI总结:

本研究提出FAULTANA计算流水线,用于分析在线互动符号网络的社会断层线,通过两个社区数据集验证了其可识别极化驱动议题、绘制情感极化时间动态,为研究在线政治极化提供了新的量化工具。

摘要:

政治冲突是民主制度的核心要素,但如果冲突过于激烈,也会威胁到民主制度的存续。当绝大多数政治议题都沿着同一条主要断层线对齐、将社会分裂为两个对立阵营时,这种情况尤其容易发生。20世纪的主要断层线由结构性冲突构成,比如所有者与工人、中心与边缘等的对立。但这些经典分裂线此后已失去了解释力。我们没有构建新的分裂理论,而是提出了FAULTANA(断层线对齐网络分析)流水线,这是一种用于在带符号的在线互动数据中挖掘主要断层线的计算方法。我们的方法能够量化不同在线辩论中普遍存在的对立程度,以及每场辩论与主要断层线的对齐程度。这使得我们能够识别驱动极化的楔子议题,这类议题同时具备强烈的对立性和对齐性。我们将该方法应用于两个大规模数据集:Birdwatch(美国推特旗下的事实核查社区)和《标准报》(DerStandard,奥地利一家在线报纸)的讨论论坛。我们发现,两个在线社区都分裂为两大群体,且这种分裂与政治身份和议题相关。此外,针对《标准报》的数据集,我们精准定位了强化社会断层线、进而驱动极化的议题。我们还识别出了会引发在线冲突、但并不严格与这些分裂线对齐的议题(例如COVID-19)。我们的方法能够构建情感极化的时间分辨率图像,展示在争议性选举和事件期间,凝聚力和分裂性分别对对齐动态的独立贡献。

英文摘要:

Political conflict is an essential element of democratic systems, but can also threaten their existence if it becomes too intense. This happens particularly when most political issues become aligned along the same major fault line, splitting society into two antagonistic camps. In the 20th century, major fault lines were formed by structural conflicts, like owners vs workers, center vs periphery, etc. But these classical cleavages have since lost their explanatory power. Instead of theorizing new cleavages, we present the FAULTANA (FAULT-line Alignment Network Analysis) pipeline, a computational method to uncover major fault lines in data of signed online interactions. Our method makes it possible to quantify the degree of antagonism prevalent in different online debates, as well as how aligned each debate is to the major fault line. This makes it possible to identify the wedge issues driving polarization, characterized by both intense antagonism and alignment. We apply our approach to large-scale data sets of Birdwatch, a US-based Twitter fact-checking community and the discussion forums of DerStandard, an Austrian online newspaper. We find that both online communities are divided into two large groups and that their separation follows political identities and topics. In addition, for DerStandard, we pinpoint issues that reinforce societal fault lines and thus drive polarization. We also identify issues that trigger online conflict without strictly aligning with those dividing lines (e.g. COVID-19). Our methods allow us to construct a time-resolved picture of affective polarization that shows the separate contributions of cohesiveness and divisiveness to the dynamics of alignment during contentious elections and events.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑