arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2307.06145econ.EM
收藏

使用外部工具变量的稳健脉冲响应:信息的作用

Robust Impulse Responses using External Instruments: the Role of Information

Davide Brignone, Alessandro Franconi, Marco Mazzali

AI总结:

本文提出代理动态因子模型(Proxy DFM),以解决外部工具变量识别在冲击不可逆和测量误差下产生偏差的问题,并通过模拟与美国货币政策应用证明其稳健性优于Proxy SVAR。

摘要:

当冲击不可逆且存在测量误差时,外部工具变量识别会导致有偏的响应。我们提出在结构动态因子模型中使用这一识别策略,并称之为代理动态因子模型(Proxy DFM)。在模拟分析中,我们表明代理动态因子模型始终能够成功恢复真实的脉冲响应,而当模型设定错误、未包含所有相关信息或存在测量误差时,代理结构向量自回归(Proxy SVAR)则系统性地无法做到这一点。在美国货币政策的实证应用中,代理动态因子模型表明紧缩性冲击明确地具有收缩效应,导致国内需求、劳动力、信贷、住房、汇率和金融市场恶化。这一结论对文献中所有可用的原始工具变量均成立。方差分解分析强调了货币政策冲击在解释经济波动中的重要性,尽管在不同时间维度上有所差异。

英文摘要:

External-instrument identification leads to biased responses when the shock is not invertible and the measurement error is present. We propose to use this identification strategy in a structural Dynamic Factor Model, which we call Proxy DFM. In a simulation analysis, we show that the Proxy DFM always successfully retrieves the true impulse responses, while the Proxy SVAR systematically fails to do so when the model is either misspecified, does not include all relevant information, or the measurement error is present. In an application to US monetary policy, the Proxy DFM shows that a tightening shock is unequivocally contractionary, with deteriorations in domestic demand, labor, credit, housing, exchange, and financial markets. This holds true for all raw instruments available in the literature. The variance decomposition analysis highlights the importance of monetary policy shocks in explaining economic fluctuations, albeit at different horizons.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑