arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2307.05575cs.SE
收藏

相互学习:架构错误在行业中是如何被沟通的?

Learning From Each Other: How Are Architectural Mistakes Communicated in Industry?

Marion Wiese, Axel-Frederik Brand, André van Hoorn

AI总结:

本文通过访谈十名德国软件架构师的扎根理论研究,考察架构错误的定义、处理与沟通方式,发现其主要局限于项目团队,并提出促进跨团队学习与错误预防的策略。

摘要:

背景。自身经验和错误决策可能成为软件架构师的重要信息来源。其他架构师的经验和错误同样可以是宝贵的信息来源。目标。在关于软件架构的错误决策(即错误)知识在实践中未得到充分共享这一假设下,本研究定性考察了软件架构师对这些错误的处理,尤其是沟通方式。方法。我们开展了一项扎根理论研究,访谈了来自不同领域的十名德国软件架构师。结果。我们识别出软件架构师对架构错误的定义、他们对这些错误的处理方式,以及他们针对这些错误偏好的沟通策略。我们发现,架构师主要在其项目团队内部沟通错误,而很少在公司内部或跨公司沟通。结论。我们提炼出若干策略,以使错误学习和预防更加有效。为了在架构师同侪群体之外共享经验和知识,公司应当投入更多努力,更有意识地讨论错误,并创造一个可以公开讨论错误的环境。

英文摘要:

Context. Own experiences and faulty decisions can be an important source of information for software architects. The experiences and mistakes of other architects can also be valuable information sources. Goal. Under the assumption that the knowledge about faulty decisions, i.e., mistakes, regarding software architecture is not shared adequately in practice, this work qualitatively investigates the handling and particularly communication of those mistakes by software architects. Method. We conducted a grounded-theory study in which we interviewed ten German software architects from various domains. Results. We identified software architects' definitions of architectural mistakes, their handling of these mistakes, and their preferred communication strategies regarding these mistakes. We found that architects communicate mistakes mainly within their project teams and seldom within or across companies. Conclusions. We derived strategies to make learning and prevention of mistakes more effective. To share experiences and knowledge beyond architects' peer groups, companies should invest more effort in discussing mistakes more consciously and create an environment where mistakes can be discussed openly.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑