三重差分(TD)设计是一种流行的因果效应识别策略,适用于研究者认为传统双重差分(DiD)的平行趋势假设不成立的情境。TD 设计在传统 2x2 DiD 的基础上增加了一个“安慰剂”层——这些观测嵌套在相同的单位和时间周期内,但已知完全不受处理影响。然而,许多 TD 应用超出了这种简单的 2x2x2 情形,使用多个时间周期内多个“安慰剂”层中许多单位的观测数据。该情境下一种流行的估计量是三重差分回归(TDR)固定效应估计量——它是 DiD 中常见的“双向固定效应”估计量的扩展。本文将 TDR 估计量分解为其组成的两组/两期/两层三重差分,并说明在任意交错采用的情境下对该参数进行因果解释需要很强的效应同质性假设,因为许多安慰剂 DiD 纳入了处于处理状态下的观测。该分解阐明了三重差分回归估计量背后隐含的识别变异,并提示研究者在比 2x2x2 情形更复杂的情境中实施这些估计量时应保持谨慎。仅纳入“干净安慰剂”的替代方法,例如对反事实进行直接插补,可能更为合适。文章最后通过将“引力模型”应用于估计 WTO/GATT 对国际贸易的影响,展示了这种插补估计量的实用性。
英文摘要:
The triple-differences (TD) design is a popular identification strategy for causal effects in settings where researchers do not believe the parallel trends assumption of conventional difference-in-differences (DiD) is satisfied. TD designs augment the conventional 2x2 DiD with a "placebo" stratum -- observations that are nested in the same units and time periods but are known to be entirely unaffected by the treatment. However, many TD applications go beyond this simple 2x2x2 and use observations on many units in many "placebo" strata across multiple time periods. A popular estimator for this setting is the triple-differences regression (TDR) fixed-effects estimator -- an extension of the common "two-way fixed effects" estimator for DiD. This paper decomposes the TDR estimator into its component two-group/two-period/two-strata triple-differences and illustrates how interpreting this parameter causally in settings with arbitrary staggered adoption requires strong effect homogeneity assumptions as many placebo DiDs incorporate observations under treatment. The decomposition clarifies the implied identifying variation behind the triple-differences regression estimator and suggests researchers should be cautious when implementing these estimators in settings more complex than the 2x2x2 case. Alternative approaches that only incorporate "clean placebos" such as direct imputation of the counterfactual may be more appropriate. The paper concludes by demonstrating the utility of this imputation estimator in an application of the "gravity model" to the estimation of the effect of the WTO/GATT on international trade.
Investigating Impacts of Health Policies Using Staggered Difference-in-Differences: The Effects of Adoption of an Online Consultation System on Prescribing Patterns of Antibiotics
Autoregressive models for panel data causal inference with application to state-level opioid policies
University of Florida(佛罗里达大学);RAND Corporation(兰德公司);Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health(约翰斯·霍普金斯大学布隆伯格公共卫生学院);Rutgers Robert Wood Johnson Medical School(罗格斯大学罗伯特·伍德·约翰逊医学院)
Does the AI Productivity Dividend Diminish? Does the AI Productivity Dividend Diminish? A Validated Framework for Identifying the Shape of Firm-Level Returns to Artificial Intelligence
Difference-in-Differences under Bipartite Network Interference: A Framework for Quasi-Experimental Assessment of the Effects of Environmental Policies on Health