保守型冒险者具有更高的未来学术影响力
Conservative adventurers have more future academic impact
AI总结:
该研究通过分析31780857篇论文的数据集,发现“保守型冒险者”在相近领域内频繁转换主题,其未来引用量比其他群体最高高出19%,为科学职业规划提供了新见解。
摘要:
部分科学家探索陌生主题,另一些则利用现有主题,但这些选择与学术表现之间的关联仍不明确。过往研究提供了相互矛盾的证据,通常依赖单一指标且忽略混杂因素。为解决这一问题,我们补充传统的主题转换频率指标,加入转换距离指标,控制混杂因素,并建立过去转换行为与未来表现之间的清晰关联。我们识别出一类被称为“保守型冒险者”的群体,他们频繁在相近领域内转换主题,与其他群体相比未来表现更出色(每篇未来论文的引用量最高可高出19%)。这种罕见的行为模式表明其在探索与利用之间实现了有效平衡。除相关性外,我们还探究保守型冒险行为是否可被有意采用为一种策略。尽管证明其有意性颇具挑战,但那些大幅转变为保守型冒险者的个体很可能是有目的地这样做,从而实现显著的表现提升。我们的研究基于涵盖物理学、生物医学和化学领域的三个数据集,共包含31780857篇主要来自20世纪至今的论文(物理学数据集时间范围为1976-2015年,生物医学和化学数据集为1900-2021年),为科学职业的理解与规划提供了见解,尤其对青年科学家具有参考意义。
英文摘要:
Some scientists explore unfamiliar topics, while others exploit existing ones, yet the link between these choices and academic performance remains unclear. Prior studies offer conflicting evidence, often relying on single metrics and overlooking confounding factors. To address this, we complement the traditional switch frequency metric with switch distances, control for confounders, and establish a clear connection between past switching behaviors and future performance. We identify a group, 'conservative adventurers', who frequently switch topics within close domains, excelling in future performance compared to others (up to 19% more citations per future paper). This rare behavioral pattern suggests an effective balance between exploration and exploitation. Beyond correlations, we question whether conservative adventuring can be intentionally adopted as a strategy. While proving intentionality is challenging, individuals who drastically transition to conservative adventurers likely do so purposefully, achieving significant performance gains. Our findings, based on three datasets covering 31,780,857 papers in physics, biomedicine, and chemistry primarily since the twentieth century (1976-2015 for physics; 1900-2021 for biomedicine and chemistry), provide insights for scientific career understanding and planning, particularly for junior scientists.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。