arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2305.17067cs.DL
收藏

开放研究数据的聚类分析及复制元数据的一个案例

Cluster Analysis of Open Research Data and a Case for Replication Metadata

Ana Trisovic

AI总结:

本文通过对哈佛Dataverse中4万余个数据集进行聚类分析,发现约20%的数据集同时包含数据和代码,提出应增设Replication元数据类型以更准确地描述此类资源并促进研究可复现性。

摘要:

研究数据通常在期刊发表时发布,以支持结果验证和可复现性。因此,研究传播基础设施通常支持来自众多学科的各种数据集,从表格数据和程序代码到音视频文件。元数据,即关于数据的数据,对于使研究成果得到充分记录并符合FAIR原则至关重要。为了推动关于研究成果元数据开发的讨论,我进行了一项探索性分析,以确定研究数据集如何根据研究人员有机地共同存放的内容进行聚类。我使用哈佛Dataverse研究数据存储库中超过40,000个数据集的内容作为聚类分析的样本。我发现大多数聚类由单一类型的数据集构成,而在其余样本中无法识别出有意义的聚类。为了解释结果,我使用了DataCite(一个记录学术记录的主要组织)所采用的元数据标准,并将现有的资源类型映射到我的结果上。约65%的样本可以用单一类型元数据(如Dataset、Software或Report)来描述,而其余部分则需要聚合元数据类型。尽管DataCite支持诸如Collection之类的聚合类型,但我认为大量数据集,特别是那些同时包含数据和代码文件的数据集(约占样本的20%),更准确地应被描述为Replication资源元数据类型。这种资源类型在促进研究可复现性方面将特别有用。

英文摘要:

Research data are often released upon journal publication to enable result verification and reproducibility. For that reason, research dissemination infrastructures typically support diverse datasets coming from numerous disciplines, from tabular data and program code to audio-visual files. Metadata, or data about data, is critical to making research outputs adequately documented and FAIR. Aiming to contribute to the discussions on the development of metadata for research outputs, I conducted an exploratory analysis to determine how research datasets cluster based on what researchers organically deposit together. I use the content of over 40,000 datasets from the Harvard Dataverse research data repository as my sample for the cluster analysis. I find that the majority of the clusters are formed by single-type datasets, while in the rest of the sample, no meaningful clusters can be identified. For the result interpretation, I use the metadata standard employed by DataCite, a leading organization for documenting a scholarly record, and map existing resource types to my results. About 65% of the sample can be described with a single-type metadata (such as Dataset, Software or Report), while the rest would require aggregate metadata types. Though DataCite supports an aggregate type such as a Collection, I argue that a significant number of datasets, in particular those containing both data and code files (about 20% of the sample) would be more accurately described as a Replication resource metadata type. Such resource type would be particularly useful in facilitating research reproducibility.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑