arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2305.11375econ.GNq-fin.EC
收藏

信用卡债务中的锚定效应

Weighing Anchor on Credit Card Debt

Benedict Guttman-Kenney, Jesse Leary, Neil Stewart

AI总结:

本文通过假设性信用卡还款实验测试去锚化干预,发现该干预能有效提高非财务困境消费者的还款额,并验证了实验反馈与实际还款行为的高度相关性。

摘要:

我们发现,未处于财务困境的消费者通常按最低还款额或接近最低还款额进行信用卡还款。这一现象难以用经济因素解释,但可以通过呈现给消费者的最低还款信息作为将还款额压低的锚点来解释。基于 Stewart (2009) 的研究,我们进行了一项假设性信用卡还款实验,以测试一种去锚化干预措施对还款选择的影响。该干预措施有效阻止了消费者选择合同最低还款额,并提高了他们的平均还款额,同时改变了还款额的分布。通过将还款选择从最低额去锚化,消费者越来越多地选择全额还款——这似乎成为了消费者的目标还款额。我们的创新之处在于将实验反馈与关于财务困境的调查反馈以及实际的信用卡还款行为联系起来。我们发现,该干预措施主要提高了财务困境较小的消费者的还款额。我们还能评估实验的潜在外部有效性,发现假设性反馈与消费者的实际信用卡还款密切相关。

英文摘要:

We find it is common for consumers who are not in financial distress to make credit card payments at or close to the minimum. This pattern is difficult to reconcile with economic factors but can be explained by minimum payment information presented to consumers acting as an anchor that weighs payments down. Building on Stewart (2009), we conduct a hypothetical credit card payment experiment to test an intervention to de-anchor payment choices. This intervention effectively stops consumers selecting payments at the contractual minimum. It also increases their average payments, as well as shifting the distribution of payments. By de-anchoring choices from the minimum, consumers increasingly choose the full payment amount - which potentially seems to act as a target payment for consumers. We innovate by linking the experimental responses to survey responses on financial distress and to actual credit card payment behaviours. We find that the intervention largely increases payments made by less financially-distressed consumers. We are also able to evaluate the potential external validity of our experiment and find that hypothetical responses are closely related to consumers' actual credit card payments.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑