精度与收缩:投资组合配置中协方差估计方法的比较分析
Precision versus Shrinkage: A Comparative Analysis of Covariance Estimation Methods for Portfolio Allocation
AI总结:
本文在最小方差投资组合配置背景下,全面比较了GGM、收缩等方法,发现GGM方法优于其他方法,并提出了一种新的超参数调优准则。
摘要:
本文在最小方差投资组合配置的背景下,对不同协方差和精度矩阵估计方法进行了全面研究。我们研究的模型集大致可分为:基于高斯图模型(GGM)的方法、收缩方法、阈值化方法以及基于随机矩阵理论(RMT)的方法。其中,GGM方法直接估计精度矩阵,而其他方法估计协方差矩阵。我们进行了合成实验以研究GGM方法的网络学习和样本复杂度性能。随后,我们比较了所有协方差和精度矩阵估计方法在日、周和月度预测期上的预测能力。我们将投资组合风险视为估计误差的指标,并将其用作比较各方法的损失函数。我们发现GGM方法优于收缩和其他方法。我们对GGM方法性能的观察与合成实验结果一致。我们还提出了一种用于GGM方法超参数调优的新准则。在合成设置中,我们的调优方法优于现有方法。我们进一步进行了实证实验,研究估计精度矩阵的性质。使用我们的调优方法计算的估计精度矩阵的性质,与合成实验和预测能力性能比较的实证实验中观察到的算法性能一致。此外,我们进行了另一项合成实验,证明了精度矩阵的估计误差与投资组合风险之间的直接关系。
英文摘要:
In this paper, we perform a comprehensive study of different covariance and precision matrix estimation methods in the context of minimum variance portfolio allocation. The set of models studied by us can be broadly categorized as: Gaussian Graphical Model (GGM) based methods, Shrinkage Methods, Thresholding and Random Matrix Theory (RMT) based methods. Among these, GGM methods estimate the precision matrix directly while the other approaches estimate the covariance matrix. We perform a synthetic experiment to study the network learning and sample complexity performance of GGM methods. Thereafter, we compare all the covariance and precision matrix estimation methods in terms of their predictive ability for daily, weekly and monthly horizons. We consider portfolio risk as an indicator of estimation error and employ it as a loss function for comparison of the methods under consideration. We find that GGM methods outperform shrinkage and other approaches. Our observations for the performance of GGM methods are consistent with the synthetic experiment. We also propose a new criterion for the hyperparameter tuning of GGM methods. Our tuning approach outperforms the existing methodology in the synthetic setup. We further perform an empirical experiment where we study the properties of the estimated precision matrix. The properties of the estimated precision matrices calculated using our tuning approach are in agreement with the algorithm performances observed in the synthetic experiment and the empirical experiment for predictive ability performance comparison. Apart from this, we perform another synthetic experiment which demonstrates the direct relation between estimation error of the precision matrix and portfolio risk.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。