在政策决策中使用已发表统计结果的风险管理
Risk management in the use of published statistical results for policy decisions
AI总结:
针对政策实施中统计结果可靠性信息不对称导致的逆向选择问题,提出研究者通过保证政策结果或风险交换与部分保险来管理风险,并以二项式结果置信区间为例说明。
摘要:
统计推断结果通常带有一定程度的可靠性度量,以供决策之用。对于政策实施者而言,实施已发表政策研究的价值关键取决于这一可靠性。对于政策研究者而言,政策实施的价值可能微弱地或完全不依赖于政策的结果。一些研究者可能因夸大统计结果的可靠性而获益。实施者可能难以或无法确定研究者是否夸大了可靠性。研究者与实施者之间的这种信息不对称可能导致逆向选择问题,即充其量政策无法实现全部效益,最坏情况下政策被认为风险过高而无法以任何规模实施。研究者可以通过保证政策结果来补救这一问题。研究者可以通过与其他研究者交换风险或仅提供部分保险来克服自身的风险规避和财富约束。问题及补救措施通过一个关于二项式政策结果成功概率的置信区间加以说明。
英文摘要:
Statistical inferential results generally come with a measure of reliability for decision-making purposes. For a policy implementer, the value of implementing published policy research depends critically upon this reliability. For a policy researcher, the value of policy implementation may depend weakly or not at all upon the policy's outcome. Some researchers might benefit from overstating the reliability of statistical results. Implementers may find it difficult or impossible to determine whether researchers are overstating reliability. This information asymmetry between researchers and implementers can lead to an adverse selection problem where, at best, the full benefits of a policy are not realized or, at worst, a policy is deemed too risky to implement at any scale. Researchers can remedy this by guaranteeing the policy outcome. Researchers can overcome their own risk aversion and wealth constraints by exchanging risks with other researchers or offering only partial insurance. The problem and remedy are illustrated using a confidence interval for the success probability of a binomial policy outcome.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。