已接受的证明:客观真理,还是文化层面的稳健性
Accepted proofs: Objective truth, or culturally robust
AI总结:
该研究围绕数学证明的接受机制展开,结合有缺陷后修正、根本错误的证明案例,探讨客观公理验证的可行性、自动证明器的作用,以及数学文化在证明接受中的必然性。
摘要:
数学界如何认定某一给定证明是正确的?基于明确公理的客观验证是否可行,还是评审者的经验与偏见必然会参与其中?自动证明器能否避开错误(以及经验与偏见)以提供客观验证?自动证明器的结论能否得到可证明的验证?我们将研究两类证明案例:一类是被发现存在缺陷但因证明思路足够稳健而得到修正的证明,另一类是曾被接受、最终被发现存在根本性错误的“证明”。这对当前学界通用的证明标准的合理性意味着什么?我们将探讨,无论我们如何努力开发万无一失的客观“证明系统”,数学文化是否都是证明被接受的过程中不可避免的一部分。
英文摘要:
How does the mathematical community accept that a given proof is correct? Is objective verification based on explicit axioms feasible, or must the reviewer's experiences and prejudices necessarily come into play? Can automated provers avoid mistakes (as well as experiences and prejudices) to provide objective verification? And can an automated prover's claims be provably verified? We will follow examples of proofs that were found to be flawed, but then corrected (as the proof plan was sufficiently robust), as well as accepted ``proofs'' that turned out to be fundamentally wrong. What does this imply about the desirability of the current community standard for proofs? We will discuss whether mathematical culture is unavoidably part of the acceptance of a proof, no matter how much we try to develop foolproof, objective ``proof systems''.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。